The NJ Police Chief Magazine - Volume 32, Number 11 | Page 14

NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 2026
differences, or quality-of-life considerations, sometimes even taking a pay cut to do so. As a result, retention has become a critical issue for agencies who invest time and resources in hiring and training officers only to lose them early in their careers.
The solution to this problem, Chief Gutsick writes, does not lie in financial incentives alone. Rather, he adds,“[ a ] gencies that focus on culture, communication, and leadership development are better positioned to retain their people. Officers want to feel supported, informed, and valued, and that begins with consistent, engaged leadership at every level of the organization.”
“ Agencies that focus on culture, communication, and leadership development are better positioned to retain their people.”
Chief Sean Gutsick, Holland Township Police
Cover of A Police Planner’ s Guidebook for Improving the Workforce Management Process, prepared in partnership with eight state chiefs’ associations, including the New Jersey State Association of Chiefs of Police.
The Michigan State PSO Guidebook, prepared in partnership with eight state chiefs’ associations, offers state perspectives on staffing issues, short briefs on a variety of staffing issues, and deeper discussions on select issues.
NEW JERSEY PERSPECTIVE
“ Across New Jersey,” Chief Sean Gutsick of Holland Township Police writes in the guidebook,“ recruitment is no longer simply about attracting candidates: it is about competing for a limited number of qualified individuals in a highly regulated and demanding environment.” Smaller and mid-sized agencies, which comprise most police agencies in the state, feel this strain the most.
The source of the strain is not necessarily pay. Rather, newer officers increasingly value time off, quality of life, and work-life balance. While departments previously could offer overtime and outside details to boost income and attract candidates, newer candidates are less focused on maximizing earnings through additional work and more on predictable schedules.
Officers are also more mobile than they have been. Rather than joining an agency and remaining with it throughout their careers, they may move in response to contract changes, scheduling
New Jersey agencies are addressing this issue in two ways. First, Chief Gutsick writes, they are“ recognizing the importance of involving the entire organization in recruitment. Every officer interaction, community engagement and public contact becomes part of the recruiting effort. Clearly defining who you are as an agency and communicating that identity effectively has become just as important as traditional hiring strategies.”
Second, once agencies have attracted officers, they succeed in retention efforts, he writes,“ by focusing on scheduling flexibility, quality-of-life improvements, and early-career support.” In addition,“ greater predictability in time off, and creating pathways for professional growth within smaller agencies can help improve retention,” while“ regional cooperation and shared resources may play a larger role... for smaller departments that cannot solve these challenges alone.”
ACTIONABLE INSIGHTS ON STAFFING ISSUES
Research briefs in the guidebook do note the importance of financial incentives, with financial compensation being among the leading influences on the decision to join or remain with a police department. Yet research also suggests that not all financial incentives may be tied to pay, and that financial incentives may not be a sustainable response to every decrease in staffing.
Among the financial incentives that agencies may offer are incentives for prior military members, stipends for bilingual officers, relocation pay, and housing assistance. Such incentives may be targeted to specific issues that officers face in a given community.
Bonuses for specified years of service may also help improve retention. The overall level of financial compensation should be
Page 12