NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 2026
RESEARCH & POLICY
Rethinking Police Staffing
New Guidebook Offers Lessons for New Jersey Workforces
By Jeremy M. Wilson, Professor and Director, Michigan State University Police Staffing Observatory, East Lansing, Michigan, and Clifford A. Grammich, Director, Birdhill Research and Communications, LLC, Downers Grove, Illinois
ABSTRACT
Police staffing challenges extend beyond recruiting to issues such as retention, leadership, supervision, workforce planning, and organizational culture. Drawing on the recent Michigan State University Police Staffing Observatory publication, A Police Planner’ s Guidebook for Improving the Workforce Management Process, this article summarizes evidence-based strategies for managing police staffing systems, with particular attention to New Jersey issues. It highlights practical lessons and actionable recommendations to help agencies strengthen their workforce, improve retention, and enhance their effectiveness.
Police agencies have long focused on how many officers they have. This question has become more pressing in recent years. Fewer persons have expressed interest in policing as a career, those who do often find other jobs while navigating long police application processes, and officers leave faster than academies can train their replacements.
Police staffing is not a single problem with a single fix. Rather, it is a system that police agencies should manage like one. Managing such a system requires attention not just to how best to recruit, train, promote, and retain staff, but also to the nature of agency workload, the allocation and deployment of resources to meet the workload, the goals and performance objectives of agency leadership and governmental authorities, and a culture that can support staff and workplace innovation. Police leaders may not have all the resources needed to understand these issues, identify the relevant connections among them, and ultimately address them.
● short briefs on staffing issues related to recruitment, promotions, turnover and retention, workplace environment, and workforce planning
● deeper discussions on select issues such as the effects of police leadership on personnel in small- and mediumsize police agencies, and the effects of span of control for police supervisors on personnel in all agencies.
Altogether, the guidebook provides an evidence-based roadmap for improving police workforce management by combining research with practical lessons from law enforcement agencies. Though not exhaustive, it highlights a wide range of staffing topics, from recruitment, hiring, and retention to leadership, supervision, workforce planning, and professional staffing integration, and how practitioners may think of them. It offers actionable strategies, case studies, and field examples for agencies of all sizes.
The Police Staffing Observatory( PSO) at Michigan State University was formed to help police leaders navigate these challenges. It applies a systems approach to police staffing, considering the full scope of police organizations as they relate to staffing. In partnership with organizations of law enforcement professionals, including the New Jersey State Association of Chiefs of Police, it works with practitioners and researchers to deliver actionable lessons for police leaders to manage their staffing systems.
A recent PSO publication, A Police Planner’ s Guidebook for Improving the Workforce Management Process: Lessons from Research and Practice, illustrates its approach. The guidebook provides
● insights from practitioners in several states, including New Jersey, on the police staffing experience
Page 11