The NJ Police Chief Magazine - Volume 32, Number 11 | Page 15

NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 2026
appropriate for the risks and hardships of the job. Increased salaries can both expand the applicant pool and boost officer satisfaction with the job while reducing attrition. officers and management may help reduce perceptions of unfair management practices and increase perceptions of procedural fairness.
Nevertheless, while financial incentives may be an immediate and sometimes necessary response to staffing levels, they are not a sustainable response for every decrease in staffing. They may not, for example, address low morale, ineffective leadership, or a negative workplace culture adversely affecting staffing levels.
Mentorship may offer a means for police agencies both to attract and retain officers. In recruiting, mentors may help applicants navigate the process of written exams, physical agility tests, background checks, and polygraph examinations, all of which recruits may find challenging. Once hired, recruits may also benefit from mentorship in navigating their first years on the job. Research indicates that mentorship programs are linked to perceived opportunities for career advancement and peer acceptance. Online resources can help police agencies establish mentorship opportunities or improve informal mentoring.
Research confirms that lack of work-life balance can cause retention problems. Similarly, unsustainable workloads, stress, and deteriorating health can lead to officers, particularly those with parental obligations, leaving the field. Poor, abusive, or unfair leadership within an agency may increase attrition, as might officer perceptions of being unheard by the organization or being left out of decision-making on issues that concern them.
Possible practices for reducing attrition include organizations taking care of officers and providing organizational support. This includes not just competitive salaries but also reducing unfair promotion practices, increasing development opportunities, instituting family-friendly policies, providing more opportunities for officers to explore career options within an agency, and facilitating changes in assignments.
Research has also asked officers themselves what would influence them to remain in the profession. Answers included work-life balance supported by reducing workloads and more flexible work schedules, as well as financial compensation for the risk and hardship of policing, and quality leadership and management. Officers also suggest advertised expectations of police work match the actual experience of front-line work. Within the field, they want better career development support and more career opportunities, specifically through educational incentives, training opportunities, and the ability to change roles. A development plan for individual employees to strengthen their performance and prepare them for future contributions can help officers envision their continuing future in law enforcement.
Police agencies can also gauge what may be influencing their officers to stay or leave. Exit interviews and officer surveys on job satisfaction can help create action plans to improve retention. In addition to seeking continuous feedback from officers about their experiences and perceptions, agencies should provide continuous feedback to officers. Continual feedback between
AGENCY LEADERSHIP AND RETENTION
The role of leadership in boosting agency morale and retention may be most evident in small agencies. To be sure, some small agencies face resource constraints that no amount of leadership skill can eliminate. Nevertheless, morale can vary greatly between agencies, even among agencies with the same resource challenges. Morale in smaller agencies may be shaped less by organizational resources than by supervisor behavior and communications.
Leadership can have a large effect on small agencies for several reasons. Officers in small agencies may work with the same supervisors over long periods. Small agencies offer fewer opportunities for officers to change assignments or escape ineffective leadership. Supervisory decisions about schedules, overtime, assignments, and training may be more visible in small agencies. More generally, executive decisions may feel more personal in small organizations.
Fairness and transparency can be particularly important for morale in smaller departments. For example, perceived favoritism will stand out quickly in small agencies and erode morale rapidly. Clear communication, consistency, and respect can help provide stability in small agencies, even in times of overwhelming work, and lead officers to view management decisions as legitimate, even when the outcome may not be ideal for them.
For all agencies, span of control for supervisors, that is, the number of employees per supervisor, can affect organizational performance. When the span of control is too large, supervisors may become overwhelmed with administrative work, provide less support and communication to their officers, and become reactive rather than proactive in their work. When the span of control is too small, organizational inefficiencies may develop and resources be underused, with too many staff in first-line supervisory positions also possibly taking them away from line positions where they are most needed.
1:5 to 1:12
The range of first-line supervisor-to-officer ratios found in prior research— the guidebook notes there is no one-size-fits-all span of control for every agency.
The guidebook suggests that there is no ideal span of control for all agencies. Previous research has found spans of first-line supervisors to officers ranging from 1:5 to 1:12. The guidebook notes a“ one-size-fits-all” approach to supervisor ratios can pose problems by not meeting the unique needs of an agency. In setting
Page 13