Legal Corner
Illegally accessing patient records
Nurse caught accessing
patient records without
proper authority.
By Scott Trueman
A
n increasing number of
hospital and health services
are collating, storing and
utilising medical and nursing records in
electronic databases. These databases
are usually protected with individualised
passwords which can be monitored and
checked to preserve patients’ privacy
and ensure that confidential medical
information is accessed on a ‘need to
know’ basis. Like any system, nothing is
fool proof or guaranteed. Unauthorised
access, whether for personal gain or
just idle curiosity is no excuse. A recent
nurse’s disciplinary tribunal hearing is an
example for all nurses to heed.
Nurse A was an experienced nurse
who had been registered since 2007
and held postgraduate qualifications in
public health and health management.
14 | nursingreview.com.au
On 14 August 2014, Nurse A while
working on a casual basis in Hospital B,
accessed a Hospital B computer in the
early hours of the morning (during night
shift) which had been logged on and left
unattended by another permanent nurse
employee.
Nurse A took this opportunity to
access district-wide electronic health
records concerning himself and six
other patients (A–F) whom Nurse A had
previously cared for. Nurse A did not
have authorised log-in credentials that
would have allowed him to access those
patient records by himself, nor did he
have any legitimate reason to access
them. The access to all seven records
involved multiple pages of each patient’s
record being opened and viewed.
At the time of the incident, Nurse A was
engaged in longstanding disputes with
patients A–F and was at a critical juncture
in acrimonious legal and administrative
proceedings with Patient A. The details of
those relationships and proceedings are
deliberately omitted from the judgement
for all patients to remain unidentified.
Needless to say, it appears that all the
disputes and disagreement proceedings
were bitter and protracted.
The alarm and/or suspicion was raised
when Patient A suspected Nurse A of
using his professional position to access
Patient A’s health records, based on
some information contained in court and
administrative documents that Nurse A
filed in late 2014.
One other particular piece of confidential
information related to a specific incident
involving Patient B, which was not general
knowledge in the proceedings and only
contained in Patient B’s medical records.
Knowledge and disclosure of this (and
other information) was of ‘benefit’ to
Nurse A in advancing his position in his
various litigious proceedings.
Suspicions widened concerning
Nurse A’s access to confidential medical
records in late 2014 and early 2015
concerning patients A, D and C to such a
level that they requested a privacy internal
review from the relevant Local Health
District under the Privacy and Personal
Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW)
and Health Records and Information and
Privacy (HRIP) Act 2002 (NSW).
The HRIP Act regulates health
information through the 15 Health Privacy
Principles, something all nurses should
have knowledge about.
THE INVESTIGATION
On 9 March 2015 Nurse A was interviewed
by a panel comprising of Hospital B’s
human resources manager, privacy
information compliance manager and
director of nursing. During that interview,
Nurse A acknowledged accessing the