Legal Corner
relevant records but denied using or
disclosing their contents. Nurse A stated
in the interview that all of the information
he had relayed in court documents was
information that he was already aware of.
Nurse A stated that he knew much of
the health information by his previous
personal interactions with Patients A–E and
because of a phone call from a friend over
a year earlier reporting the incident in detail
related to Patient B.
To Nurse A’s credit, in oral evidence,
Nurse A readily acknowledged that his
access to the health records was improper
and in breach of the relevant policies and
codes as particularised in the complaint.
He conceded that this amounted to
unsatisfactory professional conduct.
The tribunal’s peer expert, CM, was
strongly critical of the practitioner’s
conduct. CM noted that all staff working in
the public health system are bound by law,
by policies and by a strict code of conduct,
to maintain confidentiality of patient
information. CM characterised Nurse A’s
conduct as an improper use of their
professional position and a violation of
patient privacy, which evinced a disregard
for the potential harm to the professional
reputation and career of the actual staff
member whose log-in was used.
Interestingly during the hearing, Nurse A
initially sought to dispute the allegation that
he had used another staff member’s log-in
to access the records. This dispute rested
upon a characterisation of what it means
to ‘log on’. Nurse A contended that he
had not ‘logged in/on’ because he did not
actually type in the other staff member’s
credentials. Rather, when Nurse A accessed
the computer, the system had already
been logged in and active for some period
under the other staff member’s credentials.
This novel submission was rejected as it
was uncontested that Nurse A’s access
to the relevant records was unauthorised
and involved the use of a database which
was accessible only because of the other
staff member’s credentials. Accordingly,
the tribunal found that this aspect of
the complaint was established. Nurse A
ultimately conceded this and abandoned
this submission. The only real issue in
dispute was Nurse A’s motivation in
accessing the relevant records.
The tribunal found that Nurse A
opportunistically sought access to the
health records to seek information which
he could use to his advantage in his
disputes with the patients and to damage
some of the patients’ reputations, whose
privacy he breached.
The tribunal found that this was a most
serious abuse of Nurse A’s professional
position and thereby was characterised
as professional misconduct. Nurse A
was reprimanded and his registration
suspended for six months.
No matter what the intent or purpose, if
nurses in an unauthorised manner access
patient medical records – they need to
remember: curiosity may kill the cat, but
it will most certainly kill your career. Just
don’t do it! ■
Scott Trueman is a senior lecturer in
the School of Health at the University
of New England.
SUBSCRIBE FOR LESS
THAN $2 A WEEK
THE LATEST NEWS AND RESOURCES FOR
HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS
Nursing Review is essential reading for
anyone involved in the healthcare sector in
Australia. It provides unrivalled coverage of
specialist topics from features and opinion
pieces, to international news and profiles.
• Latest news and resources for all health
care professionals
• Comprehensive coverage of a diversity
of topics
• Analysis of the major issues facing the
health sector as a whole
• Delivered free of charge
• 6 issues per year
• Only publication in the country dedicated
to reporting issues important to nurses
Please call 02 9936 8666 or email subs@apned.com.au to find out more.
nursingreview.com.au | 15