industry & reform
industry & policy
their
loved
aged not
care make
might the
not
make the
decision
one in
aged one
care in might
decision
their
relative
their
relative
would
have. would have.
Indeed, this potential discrepancy
discrepancy was
was highlighted
highlighted by
by a survey
a survey conducted
in British
2014 by
British
care HC-One,
provider which
conducted in 2014 by
aged
care aged
provider
HC-One,
which
Rozenbergs
pointed
to in a piece
he Care Insite.
Rozenbergs
pointed
to in a piece
he wrote
for Aged
wrote for
In it, he Aged Care Insite
explained that of . those surveyed, only 47 per cent
it, he explained
that the
of idea
those
only 47 in per
cent
of In
residents
supported
of surveyed,
CCTV cameras
aged
care
of
residents
supported
the
CCTV
cameras in aged-
facilities,
compared
with
87 idea
per of
cent
of relatives.
care
facilities,
with 87 per cent
of a relatives.
“This
means compared
that in circumstances
where
resident “This
can no
means
that in circumstances
where cameras,
a resident it can
no longer
longer consent
to the use of CCTV
is highly
likely
consent
to the use
of CCTV
cameras,
it is highly
likely that
that a relative’s
decision
would
be against
the resident’s
wishes,”
a Rozenbergs
relative’s decision
wrote. would be against the resident’s wishes,”
Rozenbergs wrote.
Fellow Hall & Wilcox lawyer Melinda Bell said making
Fellow Hall
& Wilcox surveillance
lawyer Melinda
making
decisions
surrounding
is a Bell
way said
for older
people
decisions surrounding
is a way for
older people and
moving into aged care surveillance
facilities to maintain
independence
moving
into aged care facilities to maintain independence and
feel in control.
feel in
Bell control.
added privacy is considered a fundamental human right
Bell added privacy
is gap
considered
a fundamental
human
and contemplated
the
in surveillance
legislation
in that it
right
and really
contemplated
the
gap
surveillance
legislation
in care
doesn’t
address the
use
of in
CCTV
in a residential
aged
that
it doesn’t
really regarded
address the
use of
CCTV and
in a a residential
situation
– a place
as both
a home
workplace.
aged
care situation
place
as facility
both a and,
home
“Someone
could –
go a into
an regarded
aged care
as and
part
a workplace.
of their documentation when they go in, indicate that they
“Someone
into
aged Later,
care the
facility
and, of as attorney
part
don’t
consent could
to the go
use
of an
CCTV.
power
of
their be
documentation
when
they
go change
in, indicate
that they
might
in place and the
family
may
the wishes
of
don’t
consent to the use of CCTV. Later, the power of attorney
that person.”
might
be said
in place
and issue
the family
may mismatch
change the
wishes
Yates
a further
with this
is that
the of
ageist
that person.”
attitudes permeating society also apply within families. As an
Yates said
a further
issue might
with this
is that
the needs
ageist of
example,
family
members
not mismatch
consider the
sexual
attitudes
permeating
society also apply within families. As an
older, frailer
loved ones.
example,
family
members
consider
the sexual
needs of
“We need
to look
to the might
rights not
of people
to enjoy
agency
older,
ones.
in their frailer
lives, loved
and they
can, even if they don’t have full legal
“We need
to look
capacity,”
Yates
said. to the rights of people to enjoy agency in
their lives,
can, even
if of
they
have for
full this
legal
capacity,”
“There’s and
also they
the whole
issue
the don’t
potential
kind
of
Yates
said. surveillance to itself end up in an unsavoury way in
proposed
“There’s
also is the
whole
of and
the potential
this kind of
terms
of who
looking
at issue
whom
what gets for
kept.”
proposed
itself end
unsavoury They
way in
Bell and surveillance
Rozenbergs to
agreed
that up
this in is an
a concern.
terms
of who
is looking
at whom
and use,
what there
gets are
kept.”
said even
if there
is consent
to CCTV
issues
Bell and Rozenbergs
agreed
that this
is a concern.
They of said
even
surrounding
storage and
handling,
including
questions
who
if can
there
is consent
to CCTV
use,
there
are issues
surrounding
access
the footage,
how
long
it can
be stored
for, who storage
can
and
including
questions of who can access the footage,
view handling,
it and how
it is used.
how
long
it can
be stored
for, who can
view adults
it and and
how surveilling
it is used.
Yates
said
rather
than infantilising
older
Yates
rather in than
infantilising
older should
adults and
surveilling
them
at said
all points
time,
the discussion
focus
on
them
at all how
points
in time,
the be discussion
should
focus
on exploring
exploring
CCTV
might
used if there
is due
cause.
how
CCTV might
be used
if there
is due
cause.
Rozenbergs
agreed,
saying:
“If you
really
want to tackle elder
Rozenbergs
agreed,
saying: “If
you – really
to you
tackle
elder
abuse
– and it’s
an increasing
issue
then want
maybe
look
abuse
– and
an increasing
– then
maybe
look
at reforms
to it’s
surveillance
laws issue
to allow
aged
care you
providers
at
to surveillance
laws in to certain
allow aged
care providers
to reforms
implement
CCTV cameras
circumstances.
The
to
implement CCTV
certain
circumstances.
circumstance
might cameras
be when in
they
suspect
elder abuse.” The
circumstance
might
they
abuse.”
He added there
is be
also when
scope
for suspect
the royal elder
commission
added circumstances
there is also scope
the Royal
Commission
to He
explore
where for
consent
is not
required
to
explore
circumstances
consent
is not required
and
and
providers
move ahead where
with the
installation
of cameras,
providers
move
ahead with
the be
installation
cameras,
and added:
and added:
“Ultimately
it may
that the only
real solution
“Ultimately
it may abuse
be that
the have
only some
real solution
tackling
to tackling elder
is to
form of to
CCTV
in elder
abuse
is to have
some form of CCTV in the room.” ■
the room.”
■
THE LATEST
NEWS FOR
AGED-CARE
PROFESSIONALS
For the last 15 years, Aged Care Insite has remained
the respected industry journal aimed squarely at
the growing number of Australians working in the
burgeoning aged-care industry.
At Aged Care Insite we pride ourselves on being at the
forefront of the ever changing care sector. We provide
an independent source of news, and cover the issues
relevant to you.
• Latest updates in technology and research
• Community stories from facilities just like yours
• Comprehensive coverage of a diverse range of topics
• Regular updates via email
• Tax deductible
• Delivered bi-monthly directly to your door
Please call 02 9936 8666 to find out more.
agedcareinsite.com.au | 13
13
nursingreview.com.au