Nursing Review Issue 6 | Nov-Dec 2018 | Page 15

industry & reform industry & policy their loved aged not care make might the not make the decision one in aged one care in might decision their relative their relative would have. would have. Indeed, this potential discrepancy discrepancy was was highlighted highlighted by by a survey a survey conducted in British 2014 by British care HC-One, provider which conducted in 2014 by aged care aged provider HC-One, which Rozenbergs pointed to in a piece he Care Insite. Rozenbergs pointed to in a piece he wrote for Aged wrote for  In it, he Aged Care Insite explained that of . those surveyed, only 47 per cent it, he explained that the of idea those only 47 in per cent of In residents supported of surveyed, CCTV cameras aged care of residents supported the CCTV cameras in aged- facilities, compared with 87 idea per of cent of relatives. care facilities, with 87 per cent of a relatives. “This means compared that in circumstances where resident “This can no means that in circumstances where cameras, a resident it can no longer longer consent to the use of CCTV is highly likely consent to the use of CCTV cameras, it is highly likely that that a relative’s decision would be against the resident’s wishes,” a Rozenbergs relative’s decision wrote. would be against the resident’s wishes,” Rozenbergs wrote. Fellow Hall & Wilcox lawyer Melinda Bell said making Fellow Hall & Wilcox surveillance lawyer Melinda making decisions surrounding is a Bell way said for older people decisions surrounding is a way for older people and moving into aged care surveillance facilities to maintain independence moving into aged care facilities to maintain independence and feel in control. feel in Bell control. added privacy is considered a fundamental human right Bell added privacy is gap considered a fundamental human and contemplated the in surveillance legislation in that it right and really contemplated the gap surveillance legislation in care doesn’t address the use of in CCTV in a residential aged that it doesn’t really regarded address the use of CCTV and in a a residential situation – a place as both a home workplace. aged care situation place as facility both a and, home “Someone could – go a into an regarded aged care as and part a workplace. of their documentation when they go in, indicate that they “Someone into aged Later, care the facility and, of as attorney part don’t consent could to the go use of an CCTV. power of their be documentation when they go change in, indicate that they might in place and the family may the wishes of don’t consent to the use of CCTV. Later, the power of attorney that person.” might be said in place and issue the family may mismatch change the wishes Yates a further with this is that the of ageist that person.” attitudes permeating society also apply within families. As an Yates said a further issue might with this is that the needs ageist of example, family members not mismatch consider the sexual attitudes permeating society also apply within families. As an older, frailer loved ones. example, family members consider the sexual needs of “We need to look to the might rights not of people to enjoy agency older, ones. in their frailer lives, loved and they can, even if they don’t have full legal “We need to look capacity,” Yates said. to the rights of people to enjoy agency in their lives, can, even if of they have for full this legal capacity,” “There’s and also they the whole issue the don’t potential kind of Yates said. surveillance to itself end up in an unsavoury way in proposed “There’s also is the whole of and the potential this kind of terms of who looking at issue whom what gets for kept.” proposed itself end unsavoury They way in Bell and surveillance Rozenbergs to agreed that up this in is an a concern. terms of who is looking at whom and use, what there gets are kept.” said even if there is consent to CCTV issues Bell and Rozenbergs agreed that this is a concern. They of said even surrounding storage and handling, including questions who if can there is consent to CCTV use, there are issues surrounding access the footage, how long it can be stored for, who storage can and including questions of who can access the footage, view handling, it and how it is used. how long it can be stored for, who can view adults it and and how surveilling it is used. Yates said rather than infantilising older Yates rather in than infantilising older should adults and surveilling them at said all points time, the discussion focus on them at all how points in time, the be discussion should focus on exploring exploring CCTV might used if there is due cause. how CCTV might be used if there is due cause. Rozenbergs agreed, saying: “If you really want to tackle elder Rozenbergs agreed, saying: “If you – really to you tackle elder abuse – and it’s an increasing issue then want maybe look abuse – and an increasing – then maybe look at reforms to it’s surveillance laws issue to allow aged care you providers at to surveillance laws in to certain allow aged care providers to reforms implement CCTV cameras circumstances. The to implement CCTV certain circumstances. circumstance might cameras be when in they suspect elder abuse.” The circumstance might they abuse.” He added there is be also when scope for suspect the royal elder commission added circumstances there is also scope the Royal Commission to He explore where for consent is not required to explore circumstances consent is not required and and providers move ahead where with the installation of cameras, providers move ahead with the be installation cameras, and added: and added: “Ultimately it may that the only real solution “Ultimately it may abuse be that the have only some real solution tackling to tackling elder is to form of to CCTV in elder abuse is to have some form of CCTV in the room.”  ■ the room.” ■ THE LATEST NEWS FOR AGED-CARE PROFESSIONALS For the last 15 years, Aged Care Insite has remained the respected industry journal aimed squarely at the growing number of Australians working in the burgeoning aged-care industry. At Aged Care Insite we pride ourselves on being at the forefront of the ever changing care sector. We provide an independent source of news, and cover the issues relevant to you. • Latest updates in technology and research • Community stories from facilities just like yours • Comprehensive coverage of a diverse range of topics • Regular updates via email • Tax deductible • Delivered bi-monthly directly to your door Please call 02 9936 8666 to find out more. agedcareinsite.com.au | 13 13 nursingreview.com.au