workforce
What is bullying?
A nursing academic attempts to define the
surprisingly difficult concept of bullying.
Peter Hartin interviewed by Megan Tran
B
ullying in nursing is often dismissed as a rite of passage, yet
the definition remains poorly defined.
What exactly is bullying, and is it in the eye of the
beholder? That’s the question James Cook University’s Peter
Hartin set out to answer in a presentation at the Australian
College of Nursing’s National Nursing Forum on the Gold Coast
in August.
Hartin believes the lack of a clear definition impedes the ability
to conceptualise the phenomenon of bullying in consistent
terms, complicating potential collaboration among researchers
and contributing to inconsistent findings across studies.
28 | nursingreview.com.au
“Definitions that do exist can be vague, inconsistent and
contradictory, reflecting the complexity of bullying in the
workplace and the consequent diverse perceptions of bullying to
those who witness or experience it,” Hartin said.
He said the concept of the standard term ‘repeated behaviour’
often muddied the case and that his research aimed to improve
this definition.
Nursing Review spoke to Hartin to find out more about his
conclusions on what constitutes bullying.
NR: Peter, how has the definition of bullying changed
over time?
PH: I conducted a review on the definitions of bullying used in
the nursing profession in Australia, and it revealed that there
is no universally adhered to definition of bullying in nursing,
although many do recognise that there are many meanings of
the term bullying.
So, very few definitions are broadly recognised and integrated,
although the most common definition of bullying used in nursing
is that of the Australian government’s Fair Work Act, which states
that bullying is a repeated and unreasonable behaviour directed
towards a worker or a group of workers that creates a risk to health
and safety.
But despite there being no universally accepted definition,
there were some common themes among all the definitions. The
first theme was that most of them included an action. So that’s a