workforce
type of behaviour that must be understood as encompassing all
aspects that characterise the person in regard to bullying.
So, how has it changed over time? It used to be quite
aggressive and physical, and now it’s more covert and subtle. The
definitions have actually moved with that, which is good. So in
2013, we started to see more terms like ‘psychological’.
Also, another common theme was the relationship with time
– that is, the frequency and the duration of bullying. It’s really
interesting because it’s quite subjective. The terms used were
‘daily’, ‘gradual’, ‘consistent’, ‘cumulative’ and ‘repetitive’, and
the definitions couldn’t agree on how long an act had to go for
before it was considered bullying.
The final theme was the outcome – the result of the action.
So, regardless of the behaviour perpetrated, the outcome is quite
harmful to a person. insights just learn this behaviour too. So that’s how it feeds in to
become a culture and ingrained into the profession.
At the moment, it’s stuck in this cycle that it’s having trouble
getting out of. It all sounds a bit doom and gloom, but for the
majority of nurses, they are quite caring and don’t act in this
particular way. But for the ones who are subjected to this, it’s
quite damaging to them.
How do you define bullying? What are your plans in this area for the future?
Quite simply, I refer to it as an unreasonable behaviour to a
colleague which is harmful to a person’s safety and wellbeing.
It’s similar to most of the definitions out there, but I take out the
relationship to the frequency and the time. I do that because the
frequency and time just raises more questions than it does help.
So, from that, we start to ask questions like: Can a registered
nurse be bullied on their first day of work? With the definitions that
we have, the answer is no. Why should a registered nurse have to
endure a repeated action over a period of time in order to then
define it to report it?
I mean, it’s fascinating, and it has some flaws, but hopefully,
with some continued work, we can improve this definition to then
improve the incidence rates of bullying. This is part of the PhD that I’m undertaking. What I’ve spoken
about today – the definitions – is some of the background work.
The big picture for this study is that we really want to examine the
How does the conceptualisation of bullying become
ingrained?
It was really interesting. From 2015, in the definitions of
bullying in the nursing profession, the term ‘embedded’ was
referred to, and so this does then give some insight into the
conceptualisation of a bullying culture that has become
normalised in the nursing profession. But the danger in this
type of definition is that it may result in excusing the bullying
behaviour by the individuals who then make up the profession.
Again, it just raises more questions, because is it considered
repeated when the profession is perceived as the bully? So a staff
member can go from different wards but have this perceived
action on their very first day on each of these wards because the
bullying is so ingrained in the profession.
Is there such a thing as a rite of initiation which leads
to bullying?
Unfortunately, there is. Our research on bullying in the nursing
profession has increased substantially over the past two decades,
which is a good thing. The research has primarily been on
identifying the forms that bullying can take, measuring the
prevalence with which bullying occurs, and reporting on the
consequences of this behaviour.
Some studies have explored the organisation or precursors of
bullying, and more recently there have been studies on nursing
students’ experience of bullying while on clinical placement. These
studies have really shed some light on the idea that, unfortunately,
bullying has been dismissed in the nursing profession as a rite
of passage. It’s unfortunate because nursing students who are
typically eager and keen to learn new ways, new skills and new
Do you think that it’s an oxymoron to have the words
nursing and bullying put together, seeing that nursing is
such a caring profession?
For anyone listening who doesn’t work in health in Australia, it’s
probably surprising to hear that for the caring profession, that we
have this sort of culture going on. But unfortunately for those of
us who do work in health, it’s all too familiar.
Bullying has changed over time ...
and the definition has changed with it.
contributing factors that have allowed bullying to continue over
history. Eventually, we want to study the context of healthcare at
the time and the influence it might have had. We will be calling for
testimonies from nurses as well and hoping to hit various decades
so that we can understand.
Bullying has changed over time, and the face of bullying has
changed over time, and the definition has changed with it, which
is great. But it continues. There are also strategies in place – quite
good strategies. It’s referred to in the code of conduct as well,
which pretty much takes a ‘no bullying’ policy position. But
it continues.
We’re hoping that by examining the contributing factors
over time, we’re able to inform strategies for now. So hopefully
there have been some consistent contributing factors that we
need to hit that aren’t really being targeted by the strategies at
the moment.
What would your final message be for those nurses that are
enduring bullying?
The most important thing is to report it. What we do know is
that most people who are subjected to bullying don’t report it,
and there’s a whole other conversation of why people aren’t
reporting, and sometimes this type of behaviour is from the
person they need to report it to.
Reporting is really important, because then we can start to
track back on why this might be happening. At the moment,
nurses usually respond to bullying by debriefing with a colleague,
reducing their work hours or changing work location.
So, reporting it is number one, and then it’s always a big
question about whose responsibility it is. Is it education
providers? Is it the healthcare facilities? Is it the individual? I think
it’s a combination of all three. I think each individual can make a
huge difference. So just remember, one small step plus another
small step eventually does equal a big step, and we can do this. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 29