workforce
So there are some reasons why they
might not have improved outcomes, but
we did start the study assuming that adding
someone to help registered nurses would
improve the care.
So all in all, adding nursing support
workers to ward staffing did not lead
to improvements in patient care. Why
might we be seeing that? Why isn’t
added help improving clinical outcomes
on a broader scale?
Some reasons for that, probably, or
potentially, would be that we’ve added
somebody who was not familiar with the
ward routines or with the staff. We’ve taken
somebody who perhaps hasn’t worked on
that unit before and asked them to provide
care for a particular shift.
So they’re not part of the basic ward
staff. They’re not part of the team training.
They’re not part of the knowledge of
that ward and the knowledge of the
patients. They come in. They do a shift
and they go out.
So there could be a lack of integration
of that member of staff. There could be
a problem with the continuity of care.
Somebody comes in and provides care for
that shift and then isn’t seen again.
Also they’re an unregulated worker,
so the level of skill that they would have
would be significantly less than that of
a registered nurse. So they wouldn’t be
expected to pick up a patient deteriorating,
but they may well still be at a patient’s
18P-0585 NR - MNM General Ad Update.indd 1
bedside, but unable to pick up that the
patient was deteriorating until it was
perhaps too late.
So there are certain things about outside
staff coming in for a very short duration:
they don’t get an orientation, they don’t
feel like they’re part of a team, they might
not get much in the way of handover of a
patient’s condition, and they’re certainly
unregulated, so they’re not experienced
and they’re not at the same level of
education as a registered nurse.
We also designed the study with an
assumption that if you added someone
who was an unregulated worker to a ward,
that they would probably be involved in
rounding, so that they would do a round of
every patient on that ward, perhaps every
hour or every half an hour, depending
on the ward circumstances, so that they
would get to see all the patients.
Patients knew that they were coming
around every hour. So if the patient
needed to, for example, go to the toilet
or wanted to get out of bed, they knew
someone was going to come back within
the hour, and perhaps they wouldn’t push
the call bell.
So we did assume that that was the
model of care that would be implemented,
but of course, it wasn’t.
The AINs found themselves either part
of a team, but they were not really a team
member, or they found themselves more
frequently looking after one patient with
special needs.
And so what advice would you give to
a hospital considering adding nursing
support workers to wards?
Well, there’s since been some research
done by Linda Aiken in the United States,
and she’s found the same thing. So my
sense is that while it seems like a good idea
to add someone to assist staff, that’s not
what two studies have now found.
So the advice is that if you were going to
go down that road, you would need to be
very careful about how you implemented
it. So you would probably want to ensure
that it was a member of staff who was
added to a ward that was always on that
ward and was part of that ward staff and
was very clear what their role was and what
their activities were.
And you would probably give them
the task of rounding, going around once
every hour to see every patient, see if they
needed anything. You probably would
not have them come in to do a shift on a
ward, which is a lottery, and it’s very, very
random. And by the time they get used
to knowing what that ward is about and
perhaps what the patient is about, the
shift has passed. And they’re not part of a
team. They’re not integrated. They don’t
know what’s happening with the rest of
the team.
So the advice would be, if we go down
that road, assistants in nursing would
need to be assigned permanently to a
ward to help the registered and enrolled
nursing staff. ■
31/07/2018 11:07 | AM
nursingreview.com.au
27