workforce
worker, might have improved outcomes.
It would have given nurses more time to
spend time with patients, to spend on
perhaps some more higher-level tasks. The
assistant in nursing might have been able
to answer the call bells more rapidly, spend
more time with patients, etc.
So the gap is, we don’t know, and we
didn’t know when we started the research,
whether that would have a positive effect
or not, adding somebody to the workforce.
You looked at five wards where nursing
support workers had been added,
and looked at that against a group of
five wards where there were no nursing
support workers. So what were the
benefits of adding these workers?
Adding AINs to wards
Does it improve patient
outcomes?
Christine Duffield interviewed
by Dallas Bastian
A
round the world, more and more
nursing support workers are
being added to wards to address
ongoing staff shortages, but little is known
about their impact.
That’s the issue Australian researchers
hoped to help tackle through new research
into the addition of unregulated staff.
The study arose from an initiative of
the West Australian health department to
trial the introduction of nursing support
workers to acute care wards. These
workers were additional to the usual
staffing allocation and gave the team a
chance to look at whether restructuring
nurse staffing by adding AINs resulted
in improved patient, nurse and system
outcomes.
While the study’s authors anticipated that
adding nursing support workers to selected
26 | nursingreview.com.au
wards would improve patient care, their
analyses did not support that expectation.
They wrote: “While adding staff to support
the work of nurses logically makes sense,
the manner in which this is achieved is not
straightforward and may in fact increase
ward instability and therefore complexity,
which could have negative consequences
for patients, staff and the system.”
Still, RNs said they missed AINs when
they weren’t there.
So why does more nursing support not
always lead to improvements in clinical
outcomes?
Nursing Review spoke to study lead
Professor Christine Duffield from UTS and
Edith Cowan University.
NR: Christine, you said the effects of
the addition of unregulated nursing
support workers on nurse, patient
and system outcomes are not well
documented. What are some of the
current blind spots?
CD: We have usually not added staff to
wards. What we’ve usually done is replace
regulated workers, like registered nurses,
with unregulated workers, like assistants in
nursing. But there isn’t an endless supply of
registered nurses, so we are facing some
workforce shortages, and we do need to
think about how we might then restructure
our ward staffing.
So it seemed reasonable that adding
someone, so not replacing a member of
staff, but adding an additional unregulated
In some of the qualitative results, we found
that registered nurses did find that the
AINs were useful, that they missed them
when they weren’t there, and that they
certainly assisted in providing some basic
care. But that was in the interview part of
the data. That’s not what we found in the
rest of the studies.
When we looked at the adverse events
for patients, unfortunately, there was
a negative impact on what happened
with patients.
What were some of the negative
outcomes?
We found that on a ward where an
unregulated worker was added to the
system, there was a higher rate of urinary
tract infections and pneumonia, which
are things that nurses can prevent from
happening, because they’re there all the
time. They see deterioration. They note it.
They report it, and it’s managed quickly.
So there were some adverse events,
where the rates went up. There were
some reasons for that, potentially, that
would explain it. It may be that those
nursing support workers were added to
wards where staffing was already not
stable – where they had vacancies, for
example, or where they had heavier
patients and required more skilled nursing
than they were getting. It may also be that
the assistants in nursing were actually
‘specialing’ patients, which means they were
looking after one particular patient that was
either heavy or had some serious issues.
For example, a patient with dementia
who’s wandering on an acute medical
surgical ward is a problem, and so you have
an assistant in nursing specialing them to
make sure that they don’t go and interfere
with other patients and their treatments.