industry & reform
Eye on hygiene
Handwashing compliance
drops when health staff
think no-one’s watching.
MaryLouise McLaws interviewed
by Dallas Bastian
A
s children, our parents or guardians likely told us to wash
our hands to get rid of germs – and this directive might
still be playing a role in health professionals’ handwashing
practices, an infection control expert has suggested.
UNSW professor of medicine MaryLouise McLaws, a World
Health Organization health adviser, was speaking about her
research that revealed rates of compliance with Australian hand
hygiene guidelines drop when the job of monitoring moves from
human auditors to machines.
The study found that compliance rates fell from 94 per cent
to just 30 per cent when automated surveillance took over
from humans.
“The government has been telling us that compliance is
high,” McLaws said. “Our study shows that this may not be
the case.”
McLaws and her team compared human surveillance with
automated methods of surveillance – consisting of hand hygiene
dispensers at sinks and bedsides that record the action through
touch – in an Australian teaching hospital over two years.
The drop in compliance rates is an example of the Hawthorne
effect, the research team said. The term describes the
phenomenon of people changing their usual behaviour when they
know they are being watched.
Nursing Review spoke with McLaws about the compliance
rates we’re seeing as well as the ways the Hawthorne effect
and the handwashing advice we might have heard as children
come into play.
10 | nursingreview.com.au
NR : Why was it important to dive into this area of research?
MM: This national program of hand hygiene monitoring has
continued for eight years now, and it hasn’t had any peer
review. It’s my impression, along with other colleagues, that we
haven’t really impacted behaviour.
I’ve done some previous work at other teaching hospitals, and
while everyone is aware of the 5 Moments for Hand Hygiene, it
was an observation that they weren’t being executed as well as
could be expected.
So in 2014 we published a paper looking at some of the
problems of the methodology of the sample sizing, of how many
observations were collected during a morning of observation, and
we had a problem with that, with the validity and the reliability
to be fed back to healthcare workers about how well they were
going. So it stemmed from there.
You found that the difference between the two monitoring
methods was quite stark. Compliance rates went from
94 per cent with human auditors to 30 per cent with
automated surveillance. Were you surprised by the drop?
Sadly, I wasn’t surprised. I expected that there would be a
big difference because the national program had rolled out
surveillance of hand hygiene compliance as if it were an
intervention. So to tell healthcare workers to hand hygiene
without understanding the psyche and the psychology behind
why and when we hand hygiene was sadly disappointing for me.
I had supervised a PhD student’s thesis on behaviour, and
that we, as parents, tell our children to hand hygiene to “get the
yucky germs off”. We interviewed children and their parents
and identified that their motivation to hand hygiene is all about
self-protection, and this was back before the 5 Moments were
introduced. It was during a time when healthcare workers did
‘before and after’ hand hygiene. So this explained to us why we
thought the ‘before touching a patient’ hand hygiene compliance
was poor.
So after the 5 Moments were introduced and this rollout of
a national auditing program had continued for many years, it