news
Strength in numbers
Study shows staffing
numbers a major issue
in preventable deaths.
N
urse numbers play a key role in
preventable deaths.
That’s one of the key findings
of PhD research by Charles Darwin
University’s Dr Melanie Underwood, who
used coronial reports to analyse nurse-
related adverse events resulting in the
death of patients.
Underwood leveraged a system
originally used by the US military to
analyse failures resulting in adverse
events called the Human Factors Analysis
and Classification System, and used
99 variables such as nursing shift, type of
death, specific types of unsafe acts and
environmental factors.
“I found that almost all variables that
had led to the deaths in each case
were foreseeable and therefore often
preventable,” Underwood said.
Keep an eye on it
Nurses improve compliance
with cancer surveillance.
A
nurse-led model of colorectal
cancer surveillance has led to
more compliance with current
guidelines and has proved more successful
than its physician-led counterpart, new
research has found.
The study, published in the Medical
Journal of Australia, showed the model
also brought about a reduction in the
number of unnecessary colonoscopies and
a reduced number of cases progressing
to cancer.
Early diagnosis has a major impact on
survival and can be achieved by screening
with faecal occult blood tests or
colonoscopy, the researchers said. But
they added as many as 89 per cent of
patients receive inappropriate surveillance,
in most cases colonoscopy before the
recommended date.
For the study, the researchers focused
on two public hospitals and four private
South Australian metropolitan hospitals
where the Southern Co-operative
Program for the Prevention of Colorectal
Cancer (SCOOP) program has run for
more than 10 years.
“In the majority of cases, the number
or skill mix of nurses was related to the
unsafe act occurring.”
She said while the information
surrounding staffing numbers is not new,
particularly in remote and regional areas,
the research reinforces it as a major issue
contributing to preventable deaths.
“The research has confirmed that
unsafe acts are not single, isolated events
but the result of an error trajectory with
influencing factors at all levels of an
organisation,” she said.
“The factors contributing to error can be
identified and mitigated, which can then
prevent deaths from occurring.”
Underwood said that following a
hospital review at the time of a death,
there is often no follow up with staff at the
frontline of care to analyse the gaps in the
system leading to the failure, and how and
why it happened.
“As nurses represent the largest group
in the healthcare workforce, providing
24-hour care, they are in a key position to
contribute to improving patient safety.” ■
Prior to the introduction of the nurse-
led model in public academic hospitals
in 2000, adherence to guidelines was
46 per cent, but had jumped to 96 per cent
by 2002.
The study audited the nurse-led model
in public academic hospitals, in which
nurses make recommendations based on
NHMRC guidelines that are then confirmed
by a physician, and another model in
private hospitals in which the specialist
physician manages the entire process.
The team found that the nurse-
led model achieved a better rate of
compliance with surveillance guidelines
than that physician-led model, with rates of
97.1 per cent and 83 per cent respectively.
Study lead Dr Erin Symonds from the
Flinders Centre for Innovation in Cancer
and her colleagues said: “Having a
process in place that allows for long-term
compliance with surveillance guidelines
will promote optimal healthcare, as
procedures performed too frequently can
increase risks to patients, are expensive,
and lengthen waiting lists.
“Continuous monitoring of and
education about colonoscopy surveillance
intervals for patients at elevated risk
of CRC promotes adherence to recall
guidelines and efficient use of limited
endoscopy resources.” ■
nursingreview.com.au | 9