Nursing Review Issue 4 | Jul-Aug 2018 | Page 13
industry & reform
didn’t surprise me there was going to be a difference, but I was
disappointed that there was such a big difference.
You said the Hawthorne effect might be behind the data,
so it’d be great if you could walk me through the effect and
how it might be coming into play here.
The Hawthorne effect is something we experience daily. For
example, as we drive to and from work, we might see a speed
camera, or we might see a policeman on the side of the road,
checking our speed. We look down to see how fast we’re going
and we slow down if we have to. That’s the Hawthorne effect.
We’re doing something when we think we’re being watched
rather than doing it out of habit. The Hawthorne effect has been
observed in situations where you put a poster of a pair of eyes on a
wall and people will put their rubbish in the correct bins. Humans
respond really well to a perception they’re being watched.
So the Hawthorne effect occurs every morning when the
auditors go out there. Nurses and doctors are clever people –
they know when the auditors are there, even if the auditors are
from a different ward, because even though they are playing with
their phone, putting the data on an app, we know who’s on a
ward for security reasons. We know they’re there for a particular
reason, and usually healthcare workers twig very quickly that these
people are there to do some sort of audit. It’s become habitual to
do it in the mornings since the program was rolled out in 2010,
because the mornings are the most productive times for hand
hygiene opportunities.
So the Hawthorne effect occurs – healthcare workers increase
their hand hygiene – but it’s still not 100 per cent. So they know
when they should most of the time and they comply. It just goes
to show that if you put healthcare workers under pressure, the
perception of being watched, they will comply. Yet, there’s still
a gap between supposedly 100 per cent compliance and what
they do most of the time when they are being watched at 80 or
90 per cent.
How important do you imagine the Hawthorne effect is to
other areas of compliance? Not only across health settings,
but all work places?
Well, that’s a very interesting idea about the Hawthorne effect in
other areas. I think the most important thing that we understand
about hand hygiene, as opposed to other clinical practices, is
that we’ve been taught as children to hand hygiene to protect
ourselves. That, you know, when your parents are teaching you
Are you
responsible for
supervising
students
on clinical
placement?
© QUT 2018 23577
in your fi rst couple of years and then they stop nagging about
the age of seven, eight or nine. So you take with you an idea you
are self-protecting rather than hand hygiening for yourself and
others’ protection. There’s this deep ingrained understanding that
you have to get the yucky things off your hands. So I believe the
Hawthorne effect is probably higher in hand hygiene, even though
you’ve gone to nursing or medical school and you’ve been told
what you need to do.
That’s very different from that becoming habitual, because
of this deep, ingrained psychology of hand hygiene. And it’s a
practice that is only beneficial to the patients, really. Most of hand
hygiene is all about the patient. Sure, we hand hygiene to get
body fluids off our hands. That only happens about 12 per cent
of the time. Most of the time, your hands feel clean – they don’t
feel sticky or dirty – so to get rid of those unseen pathogens is all
about protecting the next patient, protecting the environment.
So I think the Hawthorne effect is probably highest when it
comes to hand hygiene than any other time, than any other
clinical practice that you’ve got to do during the day.
How can we get compliance rates closer to the minimum
of 70 per cent? Do we need to delve deeper into the
psychology behind those decisions?
I believe we do. I think that when we put pressure on the
healthcare workers, and under the Hawthorne effect, healthcare
workers improved while being watched. It improved for
Moment 1, for before you touch patients, which is about 35 per
cent of all of the 5 Moments. Then, after touching the patient’s
zone, because we haven’t touched the patient, but the zone
can be laden with pathogens. So those two are the ones that
improved during the Hawthorne effect.
To get it up to 70 or 80 per cent in reality, into a habitual
opportunity, we need to just focus on, first of all, Moment 1. And
remind healthcare workers that their hands are their tools, their
clinical tools, and that they need to be clean before they touch
the patient.
So I would be focusing on Moment 1. I know in NSW, in
response to our piece in the Medical Journal of Australia, the
Clinical Excellence Commission refreshed the Clean-in and
Clean‑out [campaign].
However, I still think the deep psyche of protecting ourselves is
easier to manipulate, but we really need to manipulate that pure
of heart hand hygiene from Moment 1. It’s all about the patient. So
that’s where I’d be focusing. ■
QUT’s new online short course Clinical Supervision for Health Professionals will
develop the knowledge and skills you need for providing quality clinical supervision.
Complete the online course in three hours work each week, for three weeks.
Content includes:
• The principles of learning
• Creating an optimal learning
environment
• Strategies to facilitate learning
• Providing constructive feedback
• Facilitating critical reflection
Register today to begin in September 2018.
Find out more at www.qut.edu.au/study/open-online-learning
CRICOS No. 00213J
nursingreview.com.au | 11