industry & reform
sector about $500 million or so. What do
you say to those ideas?
Staff attrition is a significant problem in our
industry, whether you’re in the home care
side or the ACFI side, with the revolving
door of staff. Again, I always look at it from
a resident’s perspective, and everybody I
speak to says it’s very frustrating getting
to know somebody and then within
two months’ time they’re gone and
replaced with a new face they have to get
familiar with.
It’s quite impersonal when you get that
revolving door side of it. There are a few
innovations I’m aware of that can stem
that, but again it comes back to “Yeah, it’s
great that taxes theoretically are going
to solve this problem”, but when I look
at the coalface, and when I look at the
frontline people which are our carers,
just about every single one that I meet
are beautiful people. They wear their
heart on their sleeve, and they’re in this
industry helping elderly people because
they love them. It seems wrong to me that
they are so poorly paid for what they do.
I think that your coalface people need to
be paid more, and whether that comes
from people’s taxes, or whether the purse
strings need to be loosened by the actual
resident, patient or whatever, you’ve got to
really look after the people at the coalface,
because to me it’s not a financial equation.
It’s got to be all about the resident.
To make it all about the resident, you
do need to make it all about the people
around them being the right people, and
the system behind them being the right
system. I agree with the study in terms of
a solution for payment is effectively that
we all pay for it, but I think there are other
options as well.
If not ratios, what about minimum
staff levels? We saw recently, when the
royal commission hit Tasmania, a case
study where a provider was not only
cutting staff, but taking staff off the floor
to spend all day looking at maximising
ACFI funding.
I think there are two problems there.
We’re all aware that for a standard aged
care facility to make money, primarily they
make it out of care. So, there is perhaps
too much time spent on working out how
to optimise payments so you can make a
living and your business is successful.
Taking staff off the floor to do that in
my book is just not on. Again, it’s got to
be all about the humanities side of it. It’s
got to be about the residents, so I do think
there is potential for a minimum floor
attendance, if you like, by staff.
For example, at most places, like what I
do, there are three rosters a day, and I have
a registered nurse across all three rosters,
and it’s a fresh RN for each shift. There’s
always somebody on there that’s senior,
and there are always enough people to
cover it, and there’s a wellness manager
over the top of that who watches it.
I’m possibly a little bit overstaffed, but
that sort of minimal staff presence is a
good thing, but not to the point where it’s
mandatory that you’ve got X amount of
people irrespective of what the care levels
are of the residents that need to be looked
after. That, I think, is going to end up in
a financial heap, but having a minimum
requirement where you know you’ve got
good staff on 24/7, as a basis, yes, I’m a
supporter of that.
You favour innovation. What does this
look like, and how does this equate to
better care for the residents?
I think the ACFI system is antiquated.
It was good 30–40 years ago, where the
care was with the organisation and they
dispensed that as they saw fit.
I think the consumer is not happy with
that system. They’re not happy with the
outcome, and they’re often not on the
same page as the actual deliverer of the
care. For example, if you’re in a standard
situation, you as an operator make more
money out of the people that are not well
than you do out of the people that are
well. So, from the business point of view,
it’s pretty hard to make ends meet if you’ve
got lots of well people and the funding
you get doesn’t allow you to make a profit.
Therefore, you tend to take people that
aren’t well.
But from the consumer’s point of view,
they want to be well. They want people
that wrap their arms around them, hug
them, love them, and help them get back
on their feet, and are as well as possible.
It’s a little bit difficult to do that when it’s
not viable from a business point of view for
all of your residents to get well, if you read
what I say.
Whereas over on the other side, I really
like the home care system. I really like the
consumer directed care model, where it’s
the resident who owns the care package,
and that means that, from a consumer’s
point of view, they retain the power.
That side of the funding system is going
to get a lot more attention, and I think
there’s a lot of room for growth. It’s a good
system, it works really well, but there’s just
not enough levels. For example, it goes
up to about level four now and there are
other bits and pieces you can get as well,
but if it went up to a level five, six or seven,
and the consumer was still in charge of
their package, it means that market forces
come into play.
Whether they’re getting that care at
home or, like in my scenario, where it’s
really a community of people with home
care packages, it means that they’re in
charge. It means they’re in control, and
that’s one of the things that all the elderly
say to me: “I don’t want my independence
taken away.”
If they own the package and can utilise
that in a home environment, or in a
community environment like what I do,
then it’s power to the people.
And then in addition to that, an
innovation that I think is important is
that there are other ways for businesses
to make money. I’m not a fan of making
money out of care, because at times that
can be a conflict of interest. If my residents
want to be really, really well, and I don’t
make my money or people in our industry
don’t make their money so much out of
the care side of it, then everybody’s on the
same page because the staff are working
hard, doing things the way they want to,
because their heart is on their sleeve –
they want people to be well, the resident
There are other ways
for businesses to make
money. I’m not a fan of
making money out of care,
because at times that can be
a conflict of interest.
wants to be well, so if you take your profit
away from making it out of care, then your
team, your business and your residents are
all aligned.
That’s a big move, and there are a few
of us in the industry in Australia doing it. It
seems to be working quite well.
If you go ahead in five or 10 years’ time
and all the boomers are there, believe me,
they will not be told, “Take what you’re
given.” They will be making choices and
they will be saying, “No, I want things on
my terms.” I think innovation will be forced
because of the nature of the boomers
coming through. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 13