industry & reform
Hundreds of nurses and aged care workers campaign for ratios. Image: AAP/Brenton Edwards
Ratios not the answer
Innovation, not ratios,
key to fixing aged care,
chief exec says.
Phil Usher interviewed by Conor Burke
R
“
atios, ratios, ratios. Everybody will
tell you that.”
This was the response of
aged care resident Merle Mitchell at the
royal commission last year when asked to
nominate one thing she would change in
the sector given the chance.
The debate over staff to patient ratios
has raged for years, and the issue has
been front and centre during the aged
care royal commission. The Queensland
state government has committed to
staffing level reports and mandated ratios.
However, federally, the government has
resisted, and the aged care sector is equally
unsure of its merits.
One issue consistently raised is the
cost of adding more nurses to an already
struggling sector. However, a report
presented to the royal commission by
the Australian Nursing and Midwifery
Federation federal secretary Annie Butler
– the Flinders University National Aged
Care Staffing and Skills Mix Project report –
12 | nursingreview.com.au
made a cost-benefit analysis of the paper’s
recommendations and found that although
it would cost $5.3 billion to implement,
any costs would be offset through tax
measures and other features.
Savings made by avoiding staff attrition is
one such feature, which currently costs the
sector $500 million.
One industry veteran who doesn’t want
to see ratios implemented is Odyssey
Health Group founder Phil Usher. He sees
innovation rather than staff quotas as the
solution to improving Australia’s aged
care system.
“I don’t think a one-size-fits-all solution
is the answer,” Usher says.
“Cherry-picking with mandatory staffing
isn’t going to fix the problem, because I
think the whole aged care system needs
an overhaul.”
Nursing Review spoke with Usher to
hear more about his ideas for a “consumer
centric” aged care system.
NR: You fear that quotas could further
complicate an already complicated
system. Can you explain the thinking
behind that?
It’s quite interesting when you look at
it from afar. For example, most people
think that problems can be resolved by
mathematical equations: somebody
might look at a standard aged care facility
and think, “Okay, the way to address the
problem is to throw more people at it.”
To me, that is not the answer, and it’s not
the answer for a couple of reasons. First, it
can be hellishly expensive to throw more
people at it, and if you get this picture in
your mind, for example, of perhaps having
an aged care facility that’s got a number of
people that are quite well, yet are forced to
have a whole pile of staff there that may be
idle – it makes no sense.
It becomes very expensive, and
somebody has to pay for that, so if the
consumer’s got to pay for that, it’s not
fair on the consumer. If the government’s
got to pay for that, it’s not fair on the
government.
I think that a better system is to be
much more personalised and try to give
the power to the people, if you like, which
is more like the consumer directed care
or the home care system, rather than the
aged care funding instrument, the ACFI
system, which is what we’re talking about
with the standardised staffing.
I think a much better system in the ACFI
side of it is to be more customised in what
the care program needs to be for the
individual. If you’ve got a pile of people that
are quite well, you have less staff. If you
have a pile of people that are not well, you
have more staff, so it has to swell and it has
to recede like the tide, as the need is there.
And the key behind that will be, how do
you fund it?
I don’t really think the answer is
mandatory staffing. It’s about being more
flexible, and where’s the money going to
come from?
The ANMF funded a paper with Flinders
University that found it would cost
$5.3 billion to implement, but any cost
would eventually be offset through tax
and other features, and that savings
would be made by avoiding staff
attrition, which they’ve found costs the