industry & reform
There’s a hole in the bucket, dear Liza,
dear Liza
So fix it, dear Henry, dear Henry,
dear Henry
With what should I fix it, dear Liza,
dear Liza?
With straw, dear Henry, dear Henry,
dear Henry
But the straw is too long, dear Liza,
dear Liza...
There’s a hole in the bucket
We know $500 million
won’t solve the problem.
So what will?
By Michael Fine
T
he royal commission’s interim
report, ominously titled Neglect,
was released on 31 October. A great
early Christmas present for all Australians,
chosen especially with the government
in mind. In response, Prime Minister
Scott Morrison joined Aged Care Minister
Richard Colbeck, Health Minister Greg
Hunt and NDIS Minister Stuart Robert on
25 November to announce another early
Christmas present: $537 million to fix the
aged care system over the next year.
As you probably know, this will fund an
extra 10,000 CDC Home Care Packages
for a year, as well as provide $25 million to
help finance programs to reduce the use of
psychoactive medicines among those who
14 | nursingreview.com.au
receive care. It also provides $10 million for
dementia training for aged care workers,
and $4.7 million to help reduce the
number of younger people with disabilities
in residential aged care.
Somewhat predictably, it seems this
wasn’t quite what most of the industry
wanted. Sean Rooney from LASA quickly
pointed out that although welcome, the
extra places were clearly not enough.
Pat Sparrow from ACSA was reported as
saying that “with some 120,000 people
waiting for a package, it wouldn’t even
touch the sides of demand”.
So, is more money really what is needed?
If so, how much more would be enough
and where would that come from? If not,
what else do we require?
Government ministers have often read
us the sermon: Throwing money at such
problems won’t fix anything. When such
troubles are endemic, more money will,
at best, just prop up the existing system.
Perhaps that’s what most players in the
existing game want.
But what else might we expect
government to do? And how might we
expect the different players to engage?
At the moment, we don’t have answers,
just more accusations and questions.
It reminds me of the old Calypso folk
song about the hole in the bucket:
In the end, you’ll probably remember,
the bucket can’t be fixed because water is
needed to fix it. Water is needed to wet the
stone, which must be done to sharpen the
axe, which is needed to cut the straw. This
is what we require to fix the hole. But how
can we fetch the water when there is a
hole in the bucket?
That’s of course where modern
plumbing comes in! Real brilliance comes
when we realise we don’t even need the
bucket, and we can forget about the straw
and the axe as well.
That’s the problem with which we enter
the new year, the beginning of the third
decade of the third millennium of this
modern and oh so clever era. We all know
there are problems. And while no one wants
to have to rely on aged care, it is something
we each may need before we die.
We all want the problems fixed. It’s just
that no one agrees on how to fix them.
In the meantime, we keep doing more of
the same things that caused the problems
in the first place.
That’s the real Christmas present we are
left with. Like climate change, the cost of
electricity, the problems of drought and
bushfires, and so many other problems
confronting us today, we expect
someone to fix the problem. But the
someone seems intent on just ignoring the
problems. Now is officially not the right
time to talk about it. Leaving the system to
fix itself means that simple issues become
complex problems, and then these in turn
become wicked problems.
Five hundred million dollars is not
enough to fix the aged care system. We all
know that. But what do we need? What do
we want next year, and what do we want
when we are the ones who need the help?
We need to change the conversation
for a start, and start talking about the next
step. But how are we going to do that,
dear Liza, when there’s such a big hole in
the bucket? ■
Michael Fine is honorary professor of
sociology at Macquarie University