n the sun-drenched villages and bustling piazzas of Sicily , the line between faith

and crime has always been blurry . For years , the Catholic Church and the mafia have coexisted in a complex way , each wielding immense influence over the lives of Sicilians . The church , with its ancient traditions and moral authority , has acted as a spiritual anchor for the island ’ s people . Yet , alongside it , the mafia has risen as a shadowy parallel power , exploiting religious rituals and symbols to legitimise its grip on society .

From funding church repairs to hijacking Easter processions , the mafia has woven itself into the fabric of Sicilian culture , using religion as both a shield and a weapon . But as the church has increasingly condemned the mafia ’ s violence , a clear divide has formed – one that exposes the tension between genuine faith and the criminals who manipulate tradition .

This uneasy coexistence between faith and crime is nothing new : it has been embedded in Sicilian life for centuries . The historical ties between the mafia and the Catholic Church stretch back to the 19th century , when the mafia emerged as a response to weak governance and foreign domination . Positioning itself as a shadow authority , the mafia mirrored the church ’ s long-standing role as a moral and social pillar . Both institutions functioned as systems of power ,

offering protection , justice and a sense of order to Sicilian communities . The mafia , aware of the church ’ s influence , often demonstrated public support for religious institutions – funding church repairs , sponsoring religious festivals and even attending mass – to foster a reputation of piety and legitimacy . This symbiotic relationship allowed the mafia to further entrench itself in Sicilian life , leveraging the church ’ s moral influence to strengthen its own grip on power .

The exploitation of religion by the mafia is not confined to history or the shadows – it is vividly portrayed in popular culture , particularly in the films we watch . Many of us will have seen Francis Ford Coppola ’ s The Godfather ( 1972 ) and marvelled at its climax , where Michael Corleone orchestrates the assassination of rival mafia bosses while attending his nephew ’ s baptism . Here , Catholic imagery is twisted to serve a violent narrative , creating an unsettling parallel rather than a stark contrast .

Both the mafia and the church rely on ritual and tradition , but while faith is meant to offer spiritual guidance , the mafia exploits these customs to reinforce its power . A reallife example came in 2016 , when mafiosi hijacked an Easter procession in the Sicilian village of San Michele Di Ganzaria , redirecting it to the home of an imprisoned

Instagram : @ papagiovanniii

boss as a show of loyalty and power . Displays like this only serve to highlight how the mafia blurs the line between faith and criminality .

At first glance , the church and the mafia might seem to share a common thread of traditionalism , but their origins and moral foundations could not be more different . Catholicism came to Sicily in Roman times , while the mafia emerged many centuries later , constructing an illusion of tradition that is ultimately hollow . While the mafia may hijack religious celebrations and symbols , it cannot lay claim to the moral authority or spiritual depth of a faith that has shaped Sicilian identity for millennia .

In 1993 , Pope John Paul II stood before the people of Agrigento and delivered a powerful condemnation of the mafia ’ s violence , quoting the Bible to draw a clear line between faith and crime : “ Dio ha detto una volta : Non uccidere .” (“ God once said : Do not kill ”.) His words served as an act of defiance and a stark reminder that true faith stands in opposition to violence , not in service of it .

But Sicily is changing . In recent years , the church has taken a firmer stance against the mafia , and many Sicilians are reclaiming their traditions from criminal influence . Faith is no longer something the mafia can so easily twist to its advantage . The divide between religion and organised crime is growing clearer , and perhaps , in time , the shadow the mafia has cast over Sicily ’ s religious life will fade for good . One thing is certain : faith endures – but it belongs to the people , not the padrini .

By Polly Watson ( She / Her ) // Third Year ; Italian and French

Page 28