the upper grades.“ The worldwide technological revolution has made school skills in math, technology, science, and formal language essential to all peoples. [ O ] ver time, the content of each of these subjects will be rethought and reorganized, and the basic outlines will increasingly be seen as the basic requirements of childhood everywhere.” Yet, Bowman pointed out, this does not mean that all families have the resources or skills to give children experience with technological games and other tools. Increasingly so, the role of technology in the home creates another possible disconnect between children’ s personal lives and school expectations. Therefore, early schooling and curriculum must rise to meet this demand for all children( personal communication, 2022).
Finally, Bowman’ s vision of a relation‐based teaching model included teachers helping children to actively treasure their home and community contexts— however distinct from the school’ s context— while at the same time helping them meet school expectations. African American Vernacular English, or Black English, is a case in point( Bowman 1989a, 1991, 2019).“ Children can learn to speak a school language that is different, whether their home language is Spanish, Urdu, Black English, or other,” she said forcefully( personal communication, 2022). Classroom management can be another site of contention between families’ and teachers’ beliefs. Along with other Black scholars( Irvine 1990; Ladson-Billings 1995), Bowman asserted that many Black children respond better to teachers’ use of a culturally relevant management style, in keeping with the concept of“ warm demanders”( Irvine & Fraser 1998). That is, effective Black teachers of Black children manage children’ s behavior through the timbre of their voice, clear directions, and insistence on performance( Irvine 1990; Cooper 2003). They also refrain from suggesting children have a choice to comply with school rules and routines when, in reality, they do not(“ Go sit down” vs.“ Will you please take your seat?” or“ Put away your toys; it’ s lunchtime” vs.“ Would you like to put away your toys and go to lunch?”). To Bowman, Black children’ s experience of a direct management style does not impede their higher‐order thinking skills. Nor does a similar style of social exchange impede their creativity, as exemplified across the Black community in its music, literature, and verbal expression, including slang( personal communication, 2022).
The Half-Truth of School Readiness
Don’ t all children learn before they get to school? They are always learning.— Barbara T. Bowman
The school readiness construct is the second principle of child development that Bowman argued gets translated as a half‐truth, to the detriment of Black and Brown children and children from families with low incomes. Here too, she said, predominant assumptions based on White, Western, and middle‐class norms are not sufficiently elastic to include all children’ s academic profiles relative to their family / community contexts( personal communication, 2022; see also 1994). Exacerbating the problem is that school readiness is based on the pervasive and popular concept that young children must be“ ready to learn” by the first day of kindergarten or they will not succeed in elementary school and later.
It is also useful to remember the history and research on school readiness, which is a term repeatedly employed over the decades, though its meaning has changed. For instance, Head Start in the 1960s concerned itself with getting children“ ready” for kindergarten; now school districts and classroom teachers regularly talk about readiness for prekindergarten and even preschool. Additionally, families are now assessed for their readiness to support children’ s readiness, as seen in the Office of Head Start’ s definition of school readiness:“ children are ready for school, families are ready to support their children’ s
Spring 2026 Young Children 43