NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 2026
LEGAL UPDATE
No Shortcut Around the Fourth Amendment
Supreme Court Holds Geofence Location Data Is a Search Under the Fourth Amendment
By Eric Daigle, Esq. | Daigle Law Group the search here was reasonable, meaning that each of its steps was properly described with particularity and found to be supported by probable cause.
The Fourth Amendment was designed to guard against general searches, but that protection is now being tested in the digital world, where law enforcement can begin an investigation not with a named suspect, but with a location, a time frame, and a request for cellphone location data. On June 29, 2026, the Supreme Court of the United States addressed that issue in Chatrie v. United States, 609 U. S. ____( 2026), a case involving a geofence warrant directed to Google after a bank robbery in Virginia. The warrant required Google to produce Location History data showing which cellphones were near the bank around the time of the robbery. At the end of the process described in the warrant, Google gave the police three names, leading the Federal Government to charge one of the individuals, petitioner Okello Chatrie, with committing the crime.
SUMMARY OF THE FACTS
Eric Daigle, Esq., Daigle Law Group
On June 29, 2026, the Supreme Court explained how the Fourth Amendment applies to the use of a geofence warrant. In doing so, the Court was tasked with considering two questions: whether the police conducted a“ search” when they obtained the cell phone location data that led to Chatrie’ s arrest, and if so, whether that search was reasonable given the features of the warrant they employed. The Court addressed only the first question at issue, holding that law enforcement conducted a Fourth Amendment search when they accessed Chatrie’ s Google Location history data by way of the geofence warrant. The Court reasoned that individuals have an expectation of privacy in cellphone records showing the location of their cellphones, and police intrude on that constitutionally protected interest when they demand the information, even though for only a limited time, and from a thirdparty tech company. As to the second question presented, the high court remanded the case to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, to consider, whether, given the warrant issued,
Chatrie arose in the wake of a robbery committed in 2019 at the Call Federal Credit Union in Midlothian, Virginia. On the day of the incident, by the time law enforcement arrived on scene, the suspect fled westward, supposedly unarmed and carrying $ 195,000 stolen from the bank’ s vault. When Detective Hylton arrived on the scene, he initiated witness interviews and undertook a review of the bank’ s security footage, however, these investigative techniques proved fruitless, as they failed to expose the suspect’ s identity. While the Detective managed to pursue two potential leads, the results were underwhelming as they resulted in two dead-ends. With no other leads to pursue, nor any additional evidence to consider, the Detective dived deeper into the little evidence he had. Reflecting back on his earlier review of the bank’ s security footage, he remembered that the suspect had carried a cell phone during the robbery. Recollection of this fact led the Detective to request and successfully obtain a geofence warrant from the County Circuit Court. The scope and subjectmatter included within the warrant proposed a geofence that included the bank, and encompassing a 150-meter radius relative to the bank’ s location.
The warrant also detailed the three-step process law enforcement expected to use in attempting to obtain the location data from Google. First, Google provides anonymized Location History data
Page 7