NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE OCTOBER 2026
LEGAL UPDATE
Passengers, Pat-Downs, and the Mission of the Stop
The Third Circuit holds in United States v. Birry that questioning a passenger for officer safety kept a traffic stop“ on mission,” and that a general request to search covered more than his pockets
By Eric Daigle, Esq. | Daigle Law Group vehicle and was joined by a second officer, Officer Shaheen. The car had two occupants: the driver, Austin Brallier, and a passenger, Christopher Birry, the defendant in this case.
Officer Pratt asked Brallier for his license and proof of insurance. Brallier admitted that the car was not insured and that he did not have his license with him, although he said he did have a valid license. Officer Pratt asked Brallier to step out of the vehicle and provide his name and date of birth, and he complied. When the officers asked where he was coming from, Brallier could not say, except that he had previously been at a garage. Asked about the passenger, Brallier responded that the man was a friend of his father and that he thought his name was Chris.
The officers radioed this information to the station and learned that the driver had an arrest warrant. Officer Pratt placed Brallier in handcuffs, explaining that he was not under arrest but was being detained until the officers could determine the status of the warrant. While placing him in the back of the patrol car, Officer Pratt told Brallier that his car would have to be towed because it was unregistered.
Eric Daigle, Esq., Daigle Law Group
In United States v. Birry, the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit examined the permissible duration of a traffic stop and the boundaries of a consent search. 1 The case arose from a traffic stop involving two occupants. The Court considered whether officers unlawfully extended the traffic stop to search the vehicle’ s passenger, and whether a full-body pat-down exceeded the scope of the passenger’ s consent.
SUMMARY OF THE FACTS
On September 11, 2023, Officer Pratt of the Blakely, Pennsylvania, Police Department noticed a car with a cracked windshield. He ran the registration and learned that it had been expired since 2017. Officer Pratt then initiated a traffic stop of the
Birry then asked Officer Shaheen if he could call a cab. Officer Shaheen responded,“ We’ ll figure it out,” and asked to see Birry’ s identification. Birry complied, providing a state identification card and explaining that he did not have a driver’ s license. Officer Shaheen asked Birry to step out of the vehicle, and the officers questioned him about his relationship with the driver. During this interaction, Officer Shaheen asked Birry to take his hands out of his pockets. After several requests that Birry keep his hands visible, Officer Shaheen asked for consent to search him, and Birry agreed.
During the pat-down, Officer Shaheen searched Birry’ s pockets and the inside of his cigarette pack. When he reached Birry’ s waistband, he noticed something in Birry’ s pant leg. He instructed Birry to put his hands on the wall and asked what was in his pant leg. Birry responded,“ What’ s in my pantleg— where?” Officer Shaheen then told Birry to put his hands behind his back so he could be detained. Birry attempted to flee but was tackled by the officers. A search of his pant leg recovered a small bag containing a loaded handgun, 27 grams of methamphetamine, 10 grams of
1 United States v. Birry, No. 25-2380, 2026 WL 2452878( 3d Cir. Aug. 21, 2026). Page 6