The NJ Police Chief Magazine - Volume 32, No. 12 | Page 29

NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE OCTOBER 2026
“ With good judgment, little else matters. Without it, nothing else matters.”
From Judgment, by Tichy ad Bennis
Each maps neatly onto the chief’ s job. Self-knowledge means understanding one’ s own blind spots and biases. Network knowledge means having trusted colleagues to call for an honest opinion. Organizational knowledge means knowing the agency’ s culture, capabilities, and informal leaders. Contextual knowledge means understanding the community, the political landscape, and the legal environment.
Few chiefs have all four in equal measure. Recognizing which one is weakest, and deliberately strengthening it, may be one of the most valuable investments a police leader can make.
BUILDING JUDGMENT THROUGHOUT THE AGENCY
Finally, Tichy and Bennis argue that the best leaders do not hoard judgment. They teach it. They explain how they approach decisions, give subordinates real calls to make, and hold them accountable for the results. In the authors’ terms, great leaders develop a“ teachable point of view” that others can learn from and apply.
For police chiefs, this is the work of succession. The sergeant who learns how the chief frames a problem, weighs stakeholders, and adjusts course is being prepared for the day he or she sits in the chief’ s chair. An agency where only the chief exercises judgment is only as strong as one person.
THE TAKEAWAY
Tichy’ s and Bennis’ s Judgment: How Winning Leaders Make Great Calls( Portfolio, an Imprint of Penguin Group).
CHARACTER AND COURAGE
Tichy and Bennis insist that process alone is not enough. Good judgment also requires character, meaning a clear set of values, and courage, meaning the willingness to act on them when it is costly. Character without courage produces leaders who know the right answer and fail to act. Courage without character produces leaders who act boldly in the wrong direction.
Chiefs face this test more often than most executives. Disciplining a popular officer, telling the governing body an unwelcome truth about staffing, or declining to support a politically attractive initiative that the chief believes is unsound all require both. The profession’ s legitimacy depends on leaders who have both.
WHAT LEADERS NEED TO KNOW
The authors also identify the kinds of knowledge that support good judgment: knowledge of oneself, of one’ s social network, of one’ s organization, and of the broader context and stakeholders.
Judgment is not a policing book, and it does not need to be. Its core lesson applies to anyone who carries responsibility for consequential decisions: slow down enough to frame the question well, bring the right people along, make the call, and stay engaged long enough to see whether it worked. Chiefs make more of these calls than most executives, often with less time and greater public scrutiny. A deliberate approach to judgment is not a luxury in the profession. It is the job.
■
Questions for police leaders, adapted from the Tichy – Bennis framework 1. What kind of call is this: people, strategy, or crisis?
2. Have I framed the issue correctly, or is there another way to define the problem?
3. Who needs to be involved or informed before I decide: governing body, unions, prosecutor, community?
4. What do I not know, and who can tell me?
5. What values are at stake, and am I prepared to act on them if the decision is unpopular?
6. How will I know whether this decision is working, and when will I check?
7. What would cause me to adjust or reverse course? 8. Who on my team could learn from how this call is made?
Page 27