NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE OCTOBER 2026
LEADERSHIP BOOKSHELF
Making the Call
What Police Leaders Can Learn from Tichy and Bennis’“ Judgment: How Winning Leaders Make Great Calls
Book Review | Judgment: How Winning Leaders Make Great Calls, by Noel Tichy and Warren Bennis
Ask a veteran police chief which moments defined his or her career, and the answer is rarely about budgets or daily operations. It is about“ calls.” Leaders are remembered for their judgment, for better and for worse.
That idea sits at the center of Judgment: How Winning Leaders Make Great Calls( Portfolio, 2007), by Noel M. Tichy and Warren G. Bennis. Tichy, a University of Michigan business professor, once ran General Electric’ s leadership development center at Crotonville. Bennis, who died in 2014, was among the most influential leadership scholars of his generation. Their book draws mostly on corporate, military, and nonprofit examples, but its framework translates with little effort to the chief’ s office. The authors put their thesis plainly: with good judgment, little else matters; without it, nothing else matters.
Their most useful insight for police leaders is that judgment is not a single moment of decision. It is a process that begins well before the call is made and continues long after.
THREE DOMAINS OF JUDGMENT
Tichy and Bennis sort the calls leaders make into three domains: people, strategy, and crisis. Every chief will recognize them.
People calls include hiring, promotion, discipline, assignments, and succession. The authors argue these matter most, because the right people in the right positions will make better calls in the other two domains. For a chief, choosing who runs patrol, who leads internal affairs, and who is being groomed as a successor shapes the department long after the chief retires.
Strategy calls set the direction of the agency: how to deploy limited staff, whether to adopt a new technology, when to pursue shared services with a neighboring town, how to respond to a change in state law. These decisions rarely feel urgent, which is exactly why they are easy to put off.
Crisis calls arrive without warning: a line-of-duty death, an officer-involved shooting, a natural disaster, a scandal. The authors observe that crises reveal judgment more than they create it. The chief who has built strong people and a clear strategy walks into a crisis with far more to draw on than one who has not.
THE PROCESS: PREPARATION, THE CALL, AND EXECUTION
The heart of the book is a three-phase process. In the preparation phase, a leader senses that a judgment call is needed, frames and names the issue, and mobilizes the people whose support will be required. The call itself follows. Then comes execution: making the decision happen, and learning and adjusting along the way.
For police leaders, the preparation phase deserves more attention than it usually gets. How a chief frames a problem often determines the answer. A rise in residential burglaries can be framed as a staffing problem, a patrol-deployment problem, a regional crime-pattern problem, or a community-engagement problem. Each framing points toward different solutions and different partners. Naming the issue well is itself an act of judgment.
Mobilizing stakeholders is equally important. A chief’ s calls ripple outward to the governing body, the business administrator, the bargaining units, the county prosecutor, neighboring agencies, and the public. Tichy and Bennis argue that leaders who skip this step may make the right call and still watch it fail. In policing, a sound decision announced without warning to the mayor or the union often becomes a fight about process instead of a discussion about merit.
THE REDO LOOP
One of the book’ s most practical ideas is what the authors call the“ redo loop.” Good leaders build in chances to correct course. Before the call, they can step back and reframe. During execution, they watch for early signs that something is not working and adjust instead of defending the original decision out of pride.
Policing already has a version of this discipline in the after-action review. The redo loop asks chiefs to apply the same thinking to administrative and strategic calls, not only to critical incidents. A new shift schedule, a restructured detective bureau, or a new early-warning system should come with a plan to measure whether it is working, and the humility to change it if it is not. Adjusting is not the same as reversing, and neither is a sign of weakness.
Page 26