The NJ Police Chief Magazine - Volume 32, No. 12 | Page 13

NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE OCTOBER 2026
in Case met that standard. The officers’ decision to wait and prepare did not eliminate the emergency. before an encounter reaches the point of unlawful force or another preventable outcome. Anger, fear, fatigue, and acute stress can narrow attention and affect decision-making. Another officer may recognize that a colleague is moving too quickly, repeating ineffective commands, or overlooking a safer option.
“ If courts are examining the whole encounter, officers and agencies must be prepared to explain the whole encounter.”
In those moments, a clear“ tap out” can protect everyone involved. An officer can take over communication, create distance, recommend a different approach, or request someone with specialized skills. Intervention should be treated as professional backup, not personal criticism.
Aviation offers a useful comparison. Crew resource management was developed after the industry recognized that communication failures and rigid cockpit hierarchies contributed to preventable crashes. Crew members learned to communicate assertively and override one another when safety required it.
Police officers can provide the same type of redundant safety system. Agencies must create a culture in which personnel expect colleagues to speak up and know how to respond when they do.
After the encounter: Qualified immunity is not a training standard
Even when officers have sufficient grounds to enter, they may retain discretion over how to proceed. If the person creating the danger is the only person at risk, officers may be able to gather more information, request additional resources, and develop a safer plan. This does not mean officers should automatically disengage from mental health emergencies or delay every entry. They must determine who is at risk, how immediate the danger is and whether waiting could place someone else in harm’ s way. An active threat to another person may require an immediate response. Ultimately, the decision depends not only on whether officers have the authority to act, but also on whether the circumstances require them to act now.
Throughout the encounter: Officers are safety systems for one another
The duty to intervene is often discussed as a legal obligation to stop another officer from committing an obvious constitutional violation. Agencies should encourage officers to intervene earlier,
Qualified immunity generally involves two questions: Was a constitutional right violated, and was that right clearly established at the time? In Zorn v. Linton, an officer used a rear wristlock and pain-compliance technique to remove a passive protester. In Scott v. Smith, officers used what the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals described as deadly restraint during an encounter with a man experiencing a mental health crisis. The qualified immunity analysis in both cases focused heavily on whether existing precedent addressed sufficiently similar conduct.
In both cases, the federal circuit courts ruled that the officers violated clearly established law. And, in both cases, the U. S. Supreme Court disagreed, noting that clearly established law cannot be decided in general terms and instead must give notice of specific conduct that is prohibited. Both cases were remanded to the circuit courts for reconsideration.
When an officer receives qualified immunity because the law was not clearly established, that does not necessarily mean the tactics were appropriate. It means the available precedent did not provide sufficiently specific notice that the conduct was unconstitutional.
Page 11