NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE OCTOBER 2026
USE OF FORCE & LIABILITY
Police Officer Decision-Making
Why the entire encounter matters
By Michael Ranalli, Reprinted with permission of Lexipol / Police1
A police encounter does not begin when an officer draws a weapon, enters a residence, or makes physical contact with a subject. A dispatch call, information in the CAD system, prior knowledge about the people involved, and decisions made while approaching the scene can all factor into the encounter.
That’ s important, because recent court decisions clarify that courts evaluating police conduct may examine the entire encounter, not only the seconds immediately before force was used. For officers, that broader view can help explain why a threat appeared credible. But it may also expose decisions they made that unnecessarily reduced distance or safer options.
The following stages provide a framework for understanding the decisions courts may examine throughout an encounter and the details officers should be prepared to articulate.
Before the arrival: The entire encounter may matter
In Barnes v. Felix, the U. S. Supreme Court rejected an analysis limited to the“ moment of threat.” The case arose from a traffic stop during which a driver began moving his vehicle. The officer stepped onto the vehicle’ s door sill and shot the driver.
Under the moment-of-threat approach, the legal analysis focused narrowly on whether the officer reasonably perceived a threat when the shots were fired. The Supreme Court held that an excessive force analysis must consider the totality of the circumstances, including events leading up to the use of force.
That broader review can work in an officer’ s favor. Prior knowledge about a dangerous person, conduct observed before force, or information provided through dispatch may help explain why an officer perceived a threat a certain way.
At the same time, the officer’ s positioning and pre-force decisions may also receive scrutiny. Consider an officer who moves directly in front of a vehicle that may flee. The driver remains responsible for disobeying lawful commands, but the officer’ s position may create a danger that did not previously exist. When circumstances allow, officers should anticipate that a driver may attempt to leave and position themselves accordingly.
Officers do not always have time to deliberate. When time is available, however, choices that preserve distance and options can protect officers and the people they encounter.
During the encounter: Consider facts together, not in isolation
Officers must evaluate the circumstances collectively rather than viewing each observation in isolation. In District of Columbia v. R. W., officers responded late at night to a report of a suspicious vehicle outside an apartment building. As officers arrived, two occupants left the vehicle and ran. One left a door open. The driver then began reversing with the door still open.
Any one of those facts might have an innocent explanation. Flight alone does not automatically establish reasonable suspicion. A vehicle reversing with an open door may not be enough by itself, either. But reasonable suspicion does not require certainty, and officers are not required to disregard the larger picture created by several observations. A“ divide and conquer” analysis separates each fact, labels it innocent, and removes it from consideration. But the U. S. Supreme Court emphasized that a more accurate analysis considers what the circumstances meant when viewed together from the officers’ perspective.
Such a distinction is also important for the incident report. Simply listing that the call occurred late at night, two people ran, and the driver reversed may not fully explain the decision to detain someone. Officers should articulate why those facts, taken together, suggested possible criminal activity.
When time is available: Slow the encounter down
Legal authority to act does not always answer the tactical questions of when and how officers should act. In Case v. Montana, a woman reported that her boyfriend appeared suicidal. He had a gun, was reportedly writing a suicide note, and may have fired a shot before communication stopped. Officers could not get anyone to answer the door. Looking into the residence, they saw an empty holster and what appeared to be a pad and paper. They also knew the man had previously threatened suicide by cop.
Rather than immediately entering, officers called the chief and assembled additional resources, including a ballistic shield and a long rifle. They took approximately 40 minutes to form a plan. During a slow, methodical search, the man emerged from a closet with a firearm and was shot in the abdomen. He survived.
The emergency aid doctrine allows officers to enter a residence without a warrant when they have an objectively reasonable basis to believe an occupant faces, or has already experienced, serious or imminent injury. The circumstances
Page 10