Part 2: The will of the Prophet in the light of the Sunnis
By: Abdul Kareem Ath-Thaqalayni
ميحرلا نمرلا هللا مسب
نيملاعلا بر هلل دمحلا و
اريثك املست ملس و نييدهملا و ةمئالا دمحم لآو دمحم ىلع هللا ىلص و
sick, he went out dragging his feet,
reclining on two persons; one of
them was `Abbas ibn `Abdul Muttalib and another man."[1] The narrator of this hadith comments
adding: "I informed `Abdullah ibn
`Abbas about what `Ayesha had
said, and he responded to me saying, `Do you know the name of the
man whom `Ayesha did not name?'
The question that can be posed is
I said: `No.' Ibn `Abbas said: `He
why would Aisha do this and lie
and fabricate things that are not true was `Ali ibn Abu Talib.'" The narand deny the Will that was given to rator continues to say that `Ayesha
does not wish `Ali any good.[2]
Ali (as)? We shall clarify in this
issue the reality of this matter and
the way Aisha spoke about Imam
This hadith is in Sahiih Al-Bukhari
Ali (as) and her hate, Yes I said it,
narrated in "the book of Wudu"
hate towards imam Ali (as).
Chapter of "Ablutions with wood
and stones" Ubadullah ibn Utab
If you desire, I may quote for you
that Aisha said that when the
all of her hadith that which shall
prove to you that she was in remote Prophet was sick............... to the
error. She has said: "When the Mes- end of the hadeeth the way she says
senger of Allah, peace be upon him "Then the prophet came with the
and his progeny, became seriously support of two men and his legs
We praise Allah and thank Him for
all of His favors and bounties and
the best of them if knowing His hujjah. The last issue we take about
“The Will of the Prophet” and the
difference from the “companions”
on the matter and of “The Will” and
the rejection of it by Aisha.
48
were dragging on the ground between Abbas and another man
"Ubaiduallah said I informed Ibn
Abbas of what Aisha said. Ibn
Abbas said,"Do you know who
was the other man? I replied in
negative Ibn Abbas said, "he was
Ail". So Aisha did not mention his
name OK and in the Sahih of muslim it is also mention volume 1
chapter21 page 379 hadith number
investigated by Sheikh al-Athari.
However, in the Musnad imam Ahmad in the investigation by alanra'uot volume 40 page67 it says
to the end of the hadeeth
and Ubaidullah said: ibn
Abbas ask me do you know that
man? He was Ali ibn abi talib
However Aisha does like
to mention him also in the Musnad
Ahmad Volume 43 al-Risalah Institution the narration is in page 86
and also al-Arna'out said, 'this narration and the chain of the narrators