Study: The Puzzle of Innovation in China | Page 16
16
FIG. 14 І INNOVATION BENCHMARKING TOOL
INNOVATION
ORGANIZATION
AND CULTURE
INNOVATION
ATTITUDE
100%
80%
60%
40%
INNOVATION
MARKET
PERFORMANCE
100%
80%
60%
90%
70%
50% 60%
80% 80%
20%
0%
40%
INNOVATION
COLLABORATION
INNOVATION
SKILLS
20%
Own firm scores
Average scores
INNOVATION IN
INDUSTRIE 4.0
INNOVATION
ACTIVITY AND
LOCALIZATION
0%
INNOVATION SCOPE
PRODUCT INNOVATION
PROCESS INNOVATION
PIONEER DISPOSITION
SPEED
COMMERCIAL SUCCESS
Top innovator scores
FIRST STEP
SECOND STEP
In the first step, the tool (see fig. 14) evaluates a company along
the seven aforementioned dimensions to draw a comprehensive
picture of its current innovation capabilities, attitudes and
practices. The evaluation is based on a thorough self-assessment
and a set of selected questions for each transformation
dimension. Depending on the responses, each dimension
receives a score between 0 and 100%. As a result, a detailed
classification of the company’s individual innovation prowess
is derived.
In addition, within each dimension, selected success criteria
provide more insight into the specific areas where a company
is shining or fading. For example, the dimension “innovation
market performance” is distinguished by the following areas:
innovation scope (types of innovation practiced), product/process
innovation, pioneer disposition, speed (time to market)
and commercial success.
To put the result into the right context and assess one’s own
capabilities and behaviors relative to others’, the evaluation is
benchmarked in a second step. Only through comparisons
with competitors and best-in-class performers do the significance
of the individual performance and the idea of how
innovative a company really is become clearer. On this basis,
individual strengths and weaknesses with regard to innovation
can be derived and potential areas for improvement identified.
In addition, it becomes possible to identify in which of the four
innovation stages a company is currently positioned.
STAGE I
STAGE II
LOCAL ADAPTORS
STAGE III
LOCAL DESIGNERS
STAGE IV
GLOBAL
INNOVATION
MOTORS
EARLY EXPLORERS