www. refrigerationandaircon. co. za 51
ENERGY PEFORMANCE
LESSONS FROM 50 NET ZERO BUILDINGS: WHAT REALLY DRIVES ENERGY PERFORMANCE?
By Eamonn Ryan
For years, net zero energy buildings have been held up as the gold standard of sustainable design. Yet while much attention is often given to renewable energy systems, a comprehensive study of 50 high-performance net zero buildings suggests that the real story lies elsewhere. technical
Speaking on the ASHRAE Journal Podcast Episode 62 released on 10 July 2026 David Traxler P. E. in conversation with editor Drew Champlin shared insights from a three-year research project analysing 50 verified net zero buildings across the US. The study found that the highest-performing projects consistently prioritised reducing energy demand before considering renewable energy generation.
" You can build a terribly inefficient building and, if you want to buy enough renewable energy or install enough on your site, you can make most buildings net zero energy. But that ' s not the goal," he says.
" The goal of the project was really to figure out if there are any patterns or basic things that most really energy-efficient buildings use." The findings revealed that regardless of location, climate or building type, the highest-performing projects consistently prioritised reducing energy demand before considering renewable energy generation.
THE IMPORTANCE OF BUILDING TIGHTNESS Many of the buildings featured exceptionally low air leakage rates, significantly reducing heating and cooling loads. " When you have a lot of infiltration in your building, you are basically heating the great outdoors," says Traxler. Many of the bestperforming projects focused on achieving airtight construction before investing in more sophisticated mechanical solutions.
Although infiltration control proved universally important, the study also highlighted how design priorities vary by geography.
Design priorities varied by climate. Colder regions generally favoured insulation levels above code minimums, while warmer climates placed greater emphasis on glazing performance and roof insulation.
Window performance emerged as a particularly influential factor across all climate zones. Traxler cites one project where upgrading from double-glazed to triple-glazed windows eliminated the need for perimeter heating altogether. " They ended up saving a significant amount of money even though the windows cost more because the mechanical system reduced so much in price."
The example highlights an important lesson for HVAC designers: investments in the building envelope can often reduce mechanical system requirements sufficiently to offset higher initial construction costs.
RACA Journal I November 2026
DESIGNING SYSTEMS THAT CAN SWITCH OFF Perhaps the most striking finding from the study was how aggressively energy-efficient buildings minimise operation when spaces are unoccupied. " Almost all of them turn things off when they ' re not being used," says Traxler.
While this sounds obvious, many conventional buildings continue operating equipment long after occupants have left. In contrast, the net zero buildings analysed were typically designed with highly zoned systems capable of responding directly to occupancy patterns. " You walk into a space and that space is served. You leave the space and shortly thereafter the heating and cooling system, the lighting and the electrical for that space, as much as possible, are turned off."
This approach extends beyond HVAC systems to lighting, plug loads and other building services, creating cumulative energy savings throughout the year.
Another recurring feature was the widespread use of Dedicated Outdoor Air Systems( DOAS), particularly in harsher climates. By treating ventilation air independently and incorporating energy recovery, these systems reduced the burden on primary heating and cooling equipment and delivered significant energy savings.
The finding aligns with broader industry trends that increasingly recognise ventilation as a specialised function requiring its own optimisation strategy.
GEOTHERMAL ' S REGIONAL ADVANTAGE The study revealed significant regional differences in HVAC system selection. In the northeastern US, Variable Refrigerant Flow( VRF) systems and ground-source heat pumps were common choices. Western states displayed the greatest variety of solutions, reflecting their more moderate climates.
" All of the net zero buildings studied in the Midwest were geothermal," says Traxler. The combination of cold winters, hot summers and high humidity appears particularly well suited to ground-source heat pumps.
The findings informed Traxler ' s subsequent research into hybrid geothermal systems, which combine ground-source heat pumps with supplementary technologies to reduce installation costs while maintaining many of their efficiency benefits.
www. refrigerationandaircon. co. za 51