clinical practice
The theme of poor or insufficient communication between
clinicians and the patient emerged repeatedly; unsurprisingly,
this is not a new challenge. Sometimes families and patients
themselves have not been told about prognosis or impending
death, so despite the presence of frailty and multiple chronic
conditions, when death comes, it can seem to be a sudden
and unexpected event. There is ongoing debate about how far
prognostic disclosure should go. We believe honest, clear and
timely communication of expectations is an ethical obligation
of clinicians.
Quality end of life care encompasses many aspects: from the
technical competencies of procedural staff to clinicians taking
time to engage with empathy and compassion, to enabling
the death to occur at a place and time of the patient’s (or their
family’s) choosing.
Older adults with life-limiting illness and informal bereaved
caregivers of older Australian patients have told us before about
their end of life priorities. They need some sense of control over
what happens near the end of their life. They have made it clear
that they want to be involved in treatment decisions made about
them. And they need clinicians to adhere to their wishes.
A recent New Zealand study confirmed that the personal traits
and behaviours of ICU clinical staff affected how families felt
about the care provided for their loved ones nearing death from
a critical illness.
Suggestions for improvement included regular and sensitive
communication with families of dying patients, more contact with
physicians, and flexibility in allowing larger number of visitors by
the bedside towards the end.
While clinicians are trained to save lives and cure disease, there
is a point where ‘if they can’t save their lives, they should save
their deaths’. Allowing a dignified death rather than prolonging
the dying process could reduce unnecessary suffering as well as
avoid giving families false hope and pathological grief.
The concept of ‘inappropriateness’, in a system where
‘everything’ is both provided by default, and is an expectation
of both society and medical culture, needs to be recognised
and discussed.
Treatments that do not impact on survival time or improve
quality of life are not in seniors’ best interests, often prevent the
achievement of a ‘good’ death and erode the sustainability of
the health system. As one family member recently told an ICU
clinician during a meeting to talk about realistic expectations
for their loved one, “Sometimes, Doctor, there are things worse
than death.”
The often default process of ‘decisions made about me
without me’ is only slowly changing. Empowering seniors and
their families to challenge clinicians and ask about treatment
burdens and realistic expectations, as well as encouraging open
and honest conversation about dying, will only improve the care
they receive. ■
Associate Professor Magnolia Cardona, Gold Coast Hospital and
Health Service and the Institute for Evidence-Based Healthcare,
Faculty of Health Sciences and Medicine, Bond University.
Nurse Ebony Lewis, School of Public Health and Community
Medicine, University of New South Wales.
Dr Alex Psirides, Intensive Care Unit, Wellington Regional
Hospital, New Zealand.
SubScribe for leSS
than $2 per week
The laTesT news and resources for
healThcare professionals
Nursing Review is essential reading for
anyone involved in the healthcare sector in
Australia. It provides unrivalled coverage of
specialist topics from features and opinion
pieces, to international news and profiles.
• Latest news and resources for all health
care professionals
• Comprehensive coverage of a diverse
range of topics
• Analysis of the major issues facing the
health sector as a whole
• Delivered free of charge
• 6 issues per year
• Only publication in the country dedicated
to reporting issues important to nurses
please call 02 9936 8666 or email subs@apned.com.au to find out more.
nursingreview.com.au | 25