clinical practice
Letting patients choose a good death
Doing ‘everything’ near the end may be
inappropriate for seniors in ICU.
By Magnolia Cardona, Ebony Lewis and Alex Psirides
N
o-one wants to be a patient in an intensive care unit.
But if you ever do require intensive care, would you or
your family like to be better informed about the harms
and benefits of intensive treatment?
And would having better information about what may happen
during the ICU stay and after help you make informed decisions,
especially if you are no longer in a position to make decisions?
A recently released review of 13 medical studies published over
the past two decades investigated just that.
The review involved 6194 older patients or relatives from
Australia, the US, Canada and France. The researchers found that
asking people about their preferences for intensive care was rare
(1 per cent to 53.6 per cent).
Less than a third (1 per cent to 34.7 per cent) were asked
about ‘goals of treatment’ – whether they wanted everything at
all costs in the hope of getting back to normal and how much
suffering they would endure to do so, or whether they would want
treatment focused mostly on their comfort. Understanding of
fears or involvement in decision-making were also low. Phrases
such as ‘dissatisfaction’ with end of life care or ‘discordance’ with
clinicians about the benefits of ICU procedures were common.
24 | nursingreview.com.au
Some patients felt that ‘too much treatment’ causes
unacceptable suffering; or when treatments were provided despite
the likelihood of improving a patient’s quality of life; or if they were
given to extend life for people in a coma with little to no chance
of recovery.
Two messages were clear. Firstly, people are aware of the
concept of ‘futility’ – providing treatment that doesn’t change
what happens to patients in either the short or long term – even
if they call it something else.
Secondly, seniors have strong opinions about such treatments
but are not often given the opportunity to express them. Some
of the reasons suggested for this lack of consultation included
patients’ cognitive impairment or advanced age, doctors’ doubts
about prognosis, paternalistic attitudes towards decision-making,
and generally a difference of opinion between health professionals
and members of the community regarding what is realistically
achievable in the ICU.
The review concluded that what was thought to be
inappropriate treatments in ICU for families and patients were
usually based on social circumstances and compassionate
grounds, and not necessarily confined to the medical aspects.
Clinicians are urged to place themselves in the patient and
family’s shoes, and involve them in reconciling these differences of
opinion. In short, by asking patients and their loved ones what they
would want, based on the best and worst case outcomes.