industry & reform
conditions that can make the patient
worse than they were before admission.
The other thing is that, even if they
survive the resuscitation attempts, the
quality of remaining life may be very poor.
And many of them die within weeks or
months of the hospital discharge anyway.
Under what circumstances would
someone need aggressive treatment?
According to our research of many years,
only people who have a real prospect
of survival in better quality of life, or the
same as when they were admitted to
hospital, should be offered both options.
If the prognosis is not going to change,
[aggressive treatments] should not
be indicated.
In some exceptional cases, patients
are admitted to intensive care for a trial
period of about 72 hours. This is in cases
where they have, for example, family
far away and they want to be saying
their goodbyes, so it’s more about a
compassionate care approach: keeping the
person alive so the family can come and
say their goodbyes.
But it’s only a very small proportion
of patients. If the patients have had an
advance care directive or a conversation
with their family, the decision to not do
those aggressive treatments could be
made earlier and the patient is spared
that suffering.
So what training should there be for staff
to recognise when death is near?
There are several prognostic tools out
there in the literature. We have developed
one at the University of NSW called
CriSTAL (Criteria for Screening and Triaging
to Appropriate aLternative care). It’s a check
list with 19 items that are readily available
from the person’s clinical history. So, as
they come to the emergency department,
the checklist can be completed in less than
three minutes if the person is known to the
emergency department. And that gives you
a score that tells you if the person is at high
risk of death within the next few months.
What we recommend with that checklist
is that the doctors and nurses who see
the patient start an honest conversation
with them about the true prognosis, the
possibility of recovery or their impending
death. And that honest conversation
could include the person’s values and
preferences for what they’re prepared to
endure in terms of aggressive treatments
or what they consider inappropriate or
excessive or unacceptable.
So the idea is, since doctors and nurses
become familiar with these prognostic
tools, they’ll be a bit more confident
about the certainty of the prognosis and
the fact that there is an impending death
in front of them and that it’s time for that
honest conversation.
Of course, their training is how to
formalise an advance care directive. So
there are multiple tools on the internet
and the NSW Health Department
where there are indications on how
to conduct the conversation, how to
document it and what to do with those
documents afterwards.
How can staff approach these
conversations with family?
It is more commonly happening in the
intensive care units, because families, I
suppose, expect that there could be a
death, because intensive care means the
patient is critically ill. In those cases, there
is a family conference, usually led by a
doctor, but it also includes the allied health
personnel and nurses treating the patients.
And that is done in a very sensitive way by
those experienced people.
The main reason these aggressive
treatments are happening outside the
intensive care unit is basically because
there is little training during the medical
and nursing courses about breaking
bad news when a person is facing
impending death.
So, the approach could start by asking
the family if they know the patient’s
wishes or their preferences or their values,
whether they value quality over quantity
of life. And they can also ask the patient
if they’re aware of the seriousness of the
illness and how they think they’re travelling
and how they think the treatment is being
beneficial to them or not.
In general, what we recommend is that
those conversations start even before
the person gets to hospital – with the GP
or with their relatives. That’s talking over
dinner about when somebody is very ill
and of advanced age, what do they want
to go through? What do they not want
to go through? And I guess, mostly, it’s
the partners of those patients who know
exactly what they want, but in some
cases and in some cultures, that topic is
still taboo.
We still recommend discussing it, even if
it’s just a little bit. Even if it’s just one single
conversation. This will all help the doctors
and nurses make decisions when the
person comes to the hospital in a crisis.
What roles do nurses in aged care
facilities play in supporting people with
writing an advance care directive?
I think the nurses have a very important
role to play. The main thing they can do
is obviously use the prognostic tools to
have their own certainty of prognosis with
the patient, but particularly in residential
aged care facilities, there is more time
than there is in an emergency situation.
So nurses in aged care facilities can assess
the patient with the checklist and can have
the conversations.
We have noted that nurses have more
ability to have those conversations and
more time than the doctors in emergency,
so we recommend that they make the
patient familiar with what an advance care
directive looks like, maybe provide them
with a printed copy of a sample or a blank
template and guide them through it, or
leave them alone to discuss it with their
families and then come back to it.
Obviously, those decisions are not
set in cement, so the advance care
directive conversations can be had several
times over the course of a particular
illness. Some patients can change
their mind about the treatment as the
disease progresses.
We also notice that families sometimes
go in one direction and the patient goes in
another. But it’s the patient who is suffering
the chronic illness and the intensive
treatment, and they may say enough is
enough. Whereas families may say, we
don’t want to let go.
So this is the sort of discussion that
needs to be held, not just with the patient
but also with the family, so there is an
agreed, shared decision.
Is there anything else you’d like to add?
Yes. The main message of this paper is that
we need to draw the line on administering
these aggressive treatments if the risks
outweigh the benefits and if the outcome
is predictably poor.
So, if we know that the person is
80 years of age, has an advanced chronic
illness, or two or more, has had previous
hospital admissions in the past few
months, is on more than six medications,
and is not an elective admission but arrived
at the emergency department, and in
particular, if they have a ‘no resuscitation’
order – all of these are flags that should
warn the doctor or nurse that this person is
eligible for an end-of-life conversation, so
that those treatments that are aggressive,
costly and painful can be prevented. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 11