industry & reform
A dignified end
Hospitals urged to avoid
aggressive treatments on
elderly patients if the risks
outweigh the benefits.
Magnolia Cardona interviewed
by Megan Tran
U
NSW medical researchers are
calling for restraint on the use of
aggressive life-saving treatments
for elderly patients, saying the focus should
be placed on making them comfortable
towards the end of their lives.
The study, led by Adjunct Associate
Professor Magnolia Cardona, reviewed 733
patients and found that a third of those
were subjected to aggressive procedures.
The median age was 68 years, but a third
of the patients were older than 80 years.
About 40 per cent of those aged 80-plus
were subjected to stringent procedures
such as incubation, intensive monitoring,
10 | nursingreview.com.au
intravenous medications, transplants and
painful resuscitation attempts.
She said these treatments brought
about unnecessary suffering for patients
by admitting them to the ICU, and
placed strain on their families and the
health system.
“Some risk factors such as a history of
presenting to the emergency room or
several hospital admissions in the past few
months, as well as not-for-resuscitation
orders, are clearly linked with poor
clinical prognosis and impending death,”
Cardona said.
“Such high-risk flags could be used as a
guide to refrain from using the emergency
team. If hospital staff were trained for
earlier recognition of when death is
inevitable, patients could be spared such
aggressive treatments and allowed a less
traumatic and more dignified end.”
Cardona said patients or families can
discuss their preferences before a health
crisis takes place and before they lose the
ability to make choices.
In particular, nurses and aged care
facilities can support people with writing
an advance care directive by providing the
relevant documents. She added that these
decisions are not permanent, and patients
can change their minds.
Nursing Review spoke with Cardona to
find out more.
NR: What are some alternatives to
aggressive treatments?
MC: Well, when the condition is irreversible
and the end of their natural life is
approaching, what is more appropriate
is to manage patients with a transition to
comfort care. And by that I mean symptom
control, pain relief, psychosocial support
to the patient, and grief counselling to the
family. It could involve moving the patient
to another unit outside of an acute care
hospital, such as a palliative care unit, or
allowing them to die peacefully at home
surrounded by their loved ones.
What are the dangers of unnecessarily
aggressive procedures?
The main problem is the prolonged
suffering. So, when these people are
subjected to intubation or intensive
care, you need therapy for resuscitation
or even organ transplants, as happened
in this study.
Then the patient suffers longer,
especially in intensive care units, develops
delirium, and could die anyway, either
during the intensive care admission or
after discharge.
Resuscitation is very painful and is
not the successful event that we see on
television or in movies. What happens is the
patient may have broken ribs or permanent
loss of consciousness and many other