Legal corner
to her sense of grievance and distress. Her
excessive workload then contributed to the
stress, of which the essential cause was Ms
H’s conduct.
The court made this statement in
passing: “It was not the legal responsibility
of the respondent [nursing home
management] to its employees to provide
a happy workplace or one in which their
productivity might have been enhanced by
temperate and polite behaviour from those
in managerial positions.”
Instead, the relevant legal responsibility
was to take reasonable care to avoid the risk
of a psychiatric injury to the claimant, in the
circumstances where she was exhibiting
vulnerability (which ought to have been
known to Ms H). The court noted the difficult
circumstances of the nursing home that
confronted Ms H as a ‘new’ manager: “It was
not Ms H’s task to avoid any conflict with
staff at the centre. The circumstances were
conducive to some tension between staff
and the new manager.”
But this did not permit Ms H to behave
towards the claimant as the trial judge found.
The court relied on a previous
judgement, which referred to a number
of factors that are likely to be relevant
in assessing whether, in the case of a
particular employee, there is a reasonably
foreseeable risk of a psychiatric injury.
They were said to include “ ... the nature
and extent of the work being done by
the employee, and the signs from the
employee concerned – whether in
the form of express warnings or the
implicit warning that may come from
frequent or prolonged absences that
are uncharacteristic”.
The implicit ‘warning’ was not in dispute
that during Ms H’s term of 10 to 11 months,
the claimant complained about her
workload. Further, the court found that the
claimant had complained to Ms H about
her conduct towards her. Liability attached
to senior nursing home management, even
though the claimant did not report her
‘difficulties’ with those senior managers
superior to Ms H; this is a warning for
‘middle’ nurse managers.
With reference to the precedent
judgement referred to above, the
court found in this particular case
that the relevant circumstances of the
claimant’s success were referrable
to her qualifications (or lack thereof)
and experience for the position, the
‘inherent’ and/or ‘implied’ requirements
of the position, the putting in place of
the direct line manager in question, and
the claimant’s complaints to anyone who
would listen about the workload issues.
The case is important for all nurse
managers. When an employee is stressed
and vulnerable, whether from their
workload or duties, the nurse manager
has a duty of care towards that nurse. To
compound the employee’s situation by
harassing and belittling them could lead to
the development of a psychiatric injury and
workplace bullying claim. That could be an
expensive lesson. The damages in this case
totalled $435,583.98. ■
Scott Trueman is a lecturer in the School
of Nursing, Midwifery and Nutrition at
James Cook University.
Supports
easy digestion
1,2
With a unique blend of prebiotics*
Our Careline team is on call for healthcare professionals and parents
Our dedicated team includes experienced Midwives, Nutritionists and Dietitians.
Their experience and knowledge about early life nutrition is available when you need it,
for specialised, unbiased advice and one-to-one support.
Call us
1800 060 057
LiveChat
www.karinourish.com
Email
careline@karinourish.com
Monday to Friday,
from 6:30am – 5:00pm (AEST)
BREAST MILK IS BEST FOR BABIES: Professional advice should be followed before using an infant formula. Introducing partial bottle feeding could negatively affect
breast feeding. Good maternal nutrition is important for breast feeding and reversing a decision not to breast feed may be difficult. Infant formula should be used as
directed. Proper use of an infant formula is important to the health of the infant. Social and financial implications should be considered when selecting a method of feeding.
*Nutricia’s patented blend of prebiotic fibre = 90% short chain Galacto-oligosaccharides (scGOS) from milk, 10% long chain Polyfructose (lc Polyfructose)
formerly known as Fructo-oligosaccharides (lcFOS) from chicory inulin. Reference