Legal corner
Legal corner
Bullying just makes it worse
When a worker is under strain at work, managers have a duty to help, not exacerbate the problem.
By Scott Trueman
Not every forceful or frank communication in the workplace is tantamount to an act of bullying. There are many misconceptions in nursing management about exactly what the legal requirements or ingredients are for a successful claim. There are essential ingredients:
• A person or a group of people repeatedly behaving unreasonably towards a worker or a group of workers at work
• The behaviour creates a risk to the health and safety of the recipient For example, managerial action carried out in a reasonable manner does not constitute bullying and may encompass:
• Performance management processes
• Disciplinary action for misconduct
• Informing a worker about unsatisfactory work performance or inappropriate work behaviour
• Asking a worker to perform reasonable duties in keeping with their job
• Maintaining reasonable workplace goals and standards.
A nursing home was recently the background for a Queensland Court of
Appeal’ s consideration of a workplace bullying claim. The claimant succeeded in her claim, in which she alleged the development of a psychiatric illness as a result of an excessive workload and the aggressive and belittling conduct of her nursing manager( Ms H).
The case was confined to 10 to 11 months in which the claimant directly reported to Ms H. The claimant alleged that Ms H acted towards her in a way that was summarised in the statement of claim as follows:
• The general tone of Ms H’ s communications and behaviour was considered to be offensive, intimidating, humiliating and threatening,
• Ms H’ s offending behaviour was alleged to be repeated, deliberate and, hence, constituting workplace harassment
• Ms H’ s conduct was belligerent and obstructive and was known by her, or ought to have been known by her, to be likely to increase the stress the claimant was feeling
• The combination of Ms H’ s conduct and the claimant’ s excessive workload had a detrimental effect upon the claimant, which was, or should have been, apparent to Ms H as the claimant’ s direct line manager.
Tellingly, there was no allegation that Ms H acted with an intention to cause an injury – specifically a psychiatric illness – to the claimant. Further, it was not alleged that she was recklessly indifferent to whether a psychiatric injury occurred. In other words, there was no allegation of an intentional tort to cause harm to the claimant. The court found that the nursing home management( particularly Ms H) should have been aware that the claimant suffered from considerable stress, which was characterised by a general negative change in her character and demeanour, causing her to appear withdrawn, worried, preoccupied and crying within the workplace.
The court found that if Ms H’ s conduct had not occurred, then the required workload would not have been enough to assert that the nursing home had breached its duty of care. In particular, there was not such a risk of the development of a psychiatric illness from lengthy working hours alone that the exercise of reasonable care required these hours to be reduced. The relevance of her excessive workload came from the conduct of Ms H( her direct manager) towards her. The burden of that workload must have made it more difficult for the claimant to cope with the harassing and belittling behaviour. And the failure by Ms H, as her manager, to reduce the claimants’ workload probably contributed
30 | nursingreview. com. au