workforce our cohort are international students. We can also use the vignettes to illustrate diseases and conditions that students may not have encountered. They allow us to model nurse / patient interactions, including looking after patients with challenging behaviours.
workforce our cohort are international students. We can also use the vignettes to illustrate diseases and conditions that students may not have encountered. They allow us to model nurse / patient interactions, including looking after patients with challenging behaviours.
We’ ve found them useful in providing nuanced and contextual data about patients: varying illnesses; socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds; different behaviours; responses to care. The vignettes can tell a whole story or we can choose to end them unresolved, allowing us to discuss in class where that vignette may have gone, where that scenario could end and what students could have done.
What did feedback reveal about students’ experiences with this approach? A key objective of the vignettes was to increase students’ ability to relate to the manikins as the case-study patients. One of the things we did to assist with that was transfer the vignettes from the screen to the lab. We dressed the manikins in the same pyjamas the actors wore, and we added other props like wigs, glasses, tattoo sleeves and jewellery. They see these visual cues in the vignette and then when they come into the lab they see them on the manikins. What we’ ve found is this helped the students overcome the idea of a generic patient that the manikin represented. That’ s what we themed‘ getting past the plastic’.
The vignettes also offer students the opportunity to view the psychomotor skills or nursing skills they are learning that week. They’ re seeing that skill portrayed within a montage of symptoms and patient personalities, in a situational context. This contextualisation not only provides them with an introduction to the skill in action, but also it situates the skill within the patient’ s particular context and needs.
As far as engagement and emotional attachment, by the end of the semester, we found that many of the students were emotionally attached to the patients, and there were two case-study patients that stood out in particular, especially in the [ student survey ] feedback. We had‘ Charlene Kennedy’, who was a young lady with a history of intravenous drug use. In the scenario, she’ s admitted for a broken leg after a motorbike accident. The other one they especially liked was a lady called Diane Coora. She was an Aboriginal woman admitted for chemotherapy, and eventually palliation, for metastatic breast cancer. We found that the students, watching the actors on screen as real people, could relate to that. In the same way that I suppose you get attached to people on television shows that you watch.
We found that some students would be discussing the case studies as if they were real people. If they got better they were happy, or if they deteriorated, as with Diane – who was [ a case study for ] palliation and was going to die – there was a general sadness around that. Many of the students described this in terms of feeling connected. Exposing students to patient stories sort of opened up the conversation between the tutor and the students, and we could discuss different perspectives and arrive at shared understandings of the patient experience.
The patient story facilitates understanding and students engaging emotionally with the story further enhances insight. It sort of fosters the development of this person-centred approach within students. Students were feeling invested in the case study, and they were kinder to the manikins.
One student told me:‘ I used to come in and just be an idiot in the lab … Now it’ s like, no wait, Charlene needs me.’
What other effects do you think the AV vignettes will have on the skills the nursing students will develop? We found that with what we could embed [ in the situations and case studies ] the opportunities are endless.
There’ s the vignette that they watch, but it also comes hand in hand with an online handover, which is a report from a nurse about the patient. Then they’ ve got patient notes and progress notes and things like that. We ended up with this multilayered view of a person, which is much like with a real person. Your understanding of that person is built up over the shift and from multiple sources; you get the story from the patient, you get the story from the patient’ s family, you get the story from the health professionals in the notes and things like that.
So with Charlene, our IV drug-using patient with the broken leg, we were using her case study in teaching pre-operative care, IV antibiotics and complex wound care. But her case study also gave us opportunity to discuss her medical and social history. We could discuss students’ values and beliefs about patients who used IV drugs. We could talk about the kind of things that lead people down this path. In her progress notes – and it never came out in the vignette – there was an entry from a fictitious social worker who was discussing her history of childhood sexual abuse.
So this case study allowed us to unpack all of that. The vignette gave a human face to that story, if you like. But we could also use Charlene to discuss pain management. The fact that she was an IV drug user meant she would have a higher tolerance to opioids, so we’ d need to give her much higher doses of pain relief to control her pain. We also made her verbally aggressive … it allowed us to discuss caring for patients with challenging behaviours. This was something we didn’ t realise students were quite worried about. Having Charlene on the screens swearing meant that we could discuss it, and we could talk about strategies to deal with behaviour, such as de-escalation techniques, in practice.
What were some of the critical factors for the success of the vignettes? Probably the most important thing was getting students to watch the online vignettes before they came to class. We found if the majority had watched it, getting a robust discussion going was much easier. How invested the actual tutor was in the lab was also important; things like making sure you demonstrate the skills with the manikin properly; for example, you address the manikin by the case-study name.
One of the most important things was [ ensuring the details in the vignettes carried over to the manikins ]. This included pyjamas, eyeglasses, and little touches like tattoo sleeves. When we do the manikins up [ with wounds or physical presentations ] we call it moulage, so [ making the moulage accurate ] is important. All of these things enhance the visual connection between the vignette and the manikin.
Is this an approach other education providers might have interest in and be able to adopt? We recently presented this paper at an international nurse education conference … and people just flooded in. This is obviously a real area of interest for health professionals.
It was originally conceived as just a technique to increase students’ engagement with manikins, but in addition to the intended outcomes, we had all those more subtle advantages. This project has enhanced realism for students, it’ s improved their learning experiences, and it’ s contributed to thoughtful and empathetic care of our manikins. We found that the key was simply to provide the plastic with some personality. ■
nursingreview. com. au | 23