Nursing Review Issue 4 | Jul-Aug 2016 | Page 24

workforce
workforce

Almost human

Danni Maguire in vignette with manikin. Photo: UTS

A

technology-enhanced approach to teaching simulations has been found to improve students’ engagement with manikins and help them reflect on their own values and pre-conceived notions about people from different cultural and social backgrounds.
Dr Tamara Power, director of health simulation at the University of Technology Sydney, led a study that looked at how students reacted to such a technology-enhanced approach. The study aimed to address a lack of empirical research investigating how to enhance engagement between nursing students and manikins.
Across 10 teaching weeks, students were introduced to five separate case studies through short vignettes. When students got to the labs, they found manikins dressed in the same props used in the films.
The researchers said feedback indicated that the intervention increased students’ ability to suspend disbelief, and feel connected to and approach the manikins in a more understanding and empathetic way.
Here, Nursing Review sits down with Power to discuss the impact the intervention had on the student experience and the factors critical to its success.
Vignettes featuring complex and diverse back stories for clinical teaching manikins are transforming the way students interact with their faux patients.
Tamara Power interviewed by Dallas Bastian
NR: Why is it important to better understand and improve the way students interact with manikins? TP: Manikins allow students a safe opportunity to master nursing skills before they go out and practise on people. Using manikins can allow students to measure and respond to complex sets of physiological symptoms, in particular deteriorating patient scenarios. Unlike real patients, manikins can tolerate the same procedure over and over again. If the students make poor decisions, and the outcome isn’ t optimal, we can always reset and start again.
However, working with manikins is different from working with humans. Obviously, they don’ t have the same emotional range, and the students can feel a little bit awkward when they’ re communicating with them. So a commonly reported issue from simulation is students struggling to suspend disbelief when they’ re doing clinical scenarios. This is because manikins lack the human characteristics of movement – particularly facial expression – and some of the subtleties of human responses. We found, in particular, that students can struggle to talk to and relate to a manikin authentically as a person.
Discussion in the literature regarding student engagement with manikins is largely anecdotal, however, so you’ ll just be reading papers and [ they might address how ] students might get a bit giggly or they’ re just awkward around the manikins. Given the absolute commitment to the use of manikins in nursing education, this created an urgency for us to explore and improve students’ perceptions of manikins and their realism, so we can develop methods for increasing engagement.
What was the intention behind introducing the vignettes? We thought that if we created these multifaceted case studies and filmed them using actors as patients and academics as nurses, the vignettes would represent the introduction of what we call a‘ virtual standardised patient’. These audiovisual [ tools ] allow students to watch a situation unfold. Much of nursing takes place behind curtains and closed doors. The vignettes essentially invite these students into that private space. So one of the things we were trying to do with these vignettes was to imbue the case-study manikins with a recognisable personality and give them a back-story and personal history.
Previous research has indicated that the use of AV vignettes is a highly effective teaching strategy, so we just paired that with the manikins. [ Because we can post the AV vignettes online ], students can access them repeatedly and watch them over and over again. We find this especially useful for students who have English as a second language – up to 30 per cent of
22 | nursingreview. com. au