technology
DEVICE FUNCTIONALITIES
Switched on
to fitness
Wearable technologies are
becoming increasingly popular,
especially in the area of fitness.
But what are the downsides?
By Sandy Fitzgerald
C
onnected health technologies such as wearables and
apps are designed to increase individual engagement in
self-care and health management. They have the potential
to improve public health due to their ability to reach a mass number
of people, at a relatively low cost, and to disseminate information and
engage consumers in health behaviour change.
Nevertheless, some people may over-engage with these
technologies and become exercise-dependent to attain unrealistic
fitness goals.
A study my colleagues and I undertook recently sought to
investigate the potential dark side of these technologies.
Respondents were asked to rank the functionalities of wearables
and apps. The following list shows the result. Devices that offer
a smartphone app, that can evaluate and provide feedback on
individual performance, and that possess tracking functionalities
(e.g. counting steps) are ranked highly by respondents.
In contrast, sharing capabilities – such as the ability to post
health performance, receive updates on friends’ or peers’ activities
and performance, and comment on friends’ or peers’ activities –
are ranked low. This suggests that people, by and large, download
these technologies to achieve an individual goal, rather than to
share and compare their exercise performance with others.
Many of these wearables and apps will need to possess a range
of these functionalities to remain popular among users.
28 | nursingreview.com.au
1. Offers a smartphone app.
2. Automatically tracks your behaviour via smartphone or
wearable device (e.g. counts steps).
3. Evaluates your performance.
4. Enables you to set performance goals.
5. Can use manual entry to track behaviour (e.g. you can enter
calories eaten or workouts performed).
6. Works with wearable devices (excluding smartphones).
7. Offers a website where you can access your activity and
performance information through a standard web browser.
8. Offers real-world rewards for achieving performance goals
(e.g. cash and prizes).
9. Can push notifications to wearable devices or smartphone via
audible tone, physical feedback (e.g. vibration) and visual display.
10. Offers virtual rewards for achieving performance goals (e.g.
virtual trophies and medals).
11. Allows you and your friends or peers to comment or
acknowledge each other’s activity and performance.
12. Can show you updates on friends’ or peers’ activities.
13. Can post your activity and performance to others or other
social platforms such as Facebook or Twitter.
It is possible that the device functionalities could prompt certain
individuals to become exercise-dependent in pursuit of fitness
goals. Exercise dependency can be described as a compulsive
engagement in physical exercise, despite negative consequences,
such as exhaustion, and physical and mental stress.
An exercise-dependent individual exhibits behavioural (high
levels of exercise frequency), psychological (strong commitment
to exercise) and physiological (high physical tolerance and
endurance) responses to exercise.
Given that the functionalities of these wearables and apps are
to engage users to exercise more, our study investigates which
functionalities positively correlate with exercise-dependent
individuals. We found that three device attributes positively
correlate with exercise dependency, namely:
1. Offers a website where you can access your activity and
performance information through a standard web browser.
2. Includes the ability to show updates on friends’ or peers’
activities and performance on a device.
3. Enables you to set performance goals.
Unsurprisingly, goal-setting and real-time performance tracking
correspond with greater levels of exercise dependency. This
is because exercise-dependent individuals need personalised
exercise data to inform them of their progress.
Social features, which were not ranked highly in an absolute
sense, also correlate with greater levels of exercise dependency.
This apparent paradox may be because social features
disproportionately correspond with exercise dependence for
only certain types of users. In other words, exercise-dependent
individuals particularly use the social platform to brag about their
level of fitness to others.
While the benefits of using wearables and apps to improve and
maintain fitness goals are evident, our study aims to caution users
of the potential traps and harm of using popular wearables and
apps in the overzealous pursuit of fitness goals through exercise. ■
Dr Sandy Fitzgerald is a lecturer in marketing at RMIT University.
Professors Mike Reid and Lisa Farrell, assistant professor Luke
Kachersky, Dr Kaleel Rahman and Natalya Saldanha contributed
research to this project.