technology
To address some of those concerns, you trialled facial
recognition technology with your radio oncology patients.
What technology was used in that trial and how was it used?
We were lucky enough to be working with a company that was also
thinking in that space, with Gabriel Cares. And so we were able to
borrow some technology from them and try two different types of
technology.
We trialled facial r ecognition technology where we enrolled
the patients, and then as they arrived each time after that into the
clinic waiting area for their treatment, their faces were recognised
by a camera and … the staff at the desks were able to get the
name, date of birth and address of the person, and welcome the
person by name as they came into the waiting area and then the
treatment area.
While we borrowed the technology, we also trialled using
swipe cards for patients, a patient ID card. So we created cards
to put their faces on the card, and it had a code, so that when
the patients arrived they could swipe it on an iPad and actually
confirm their details as they arrived at the clinic and then arrived in
the treatment area.
So we tried two different ways of seeing how patients enjoyed
the experience of doing those different ways of arriving.
Were those technologies reliable for patient identification?
Yes. The swipe card was 100 per cent reliable because patients
actually stopped and confirmed, themselves.
The facial recognition technology wasn’t inaccurate, but we were
learning as we were setting it up – how to get the lighting and the
settings accurate. So it didn’t tell us that somebody was somebody
else, but there was one instance out of the 30 patients we had where
it wasn’t able to [confirm the patient’s identity], so it just said: “I’m not
able to confirm in this instance.” [So in that] case we went back to the
three normal identifiers and asking the questions.
We did learn that if we change the lighting so that the picture of
the patient as they walked into the waiting room was clearer, we
would then get 100 per cent compliance.
You said patients were surprised you weren’t already using
technology like this in the identification process. Was that a
surprising finding, and what else did patients have to say about
being identified through these types of technology?
Before we started trialling the two different interventions, we
asked the patients … whether they minded having to give their
details each time and whether they would be willing to try
technology. And that’s [when they said]: “We can’t believe you
don’t do this already.” But in health, our IT systems aren’t always
as sophisticated as those of banks or security firms or when you
go through passport checks at airports. So we rely a lot on people
doing things manually.
So yes, patients were surprised and it was just good to hear
them say that, because we often think that’s the case, but we were
actually able to confirm that in our interviews.
The patients loved the facial recognition technology. They just
thought it was wonderful that people knew who they were, that
they didn’t have to keep saying the same repetitious details over
and over again. Because we did that first, we’re not sure whether
they weren’t quite as enamoured with the swipe card because it
seemed like going backwards after that had the whiz-bang facial
recognition technology. But we did find that with patients where
English wasn’t their first language, they actually loved the ID cards
because they were in control of their own arrival at the clinic and
their own identification instead of having to rely on somebody
else. And I think they felt more in control of it than just the facial
recognition technology that happened around them without them
being aware that it was happening.
And how did staff feel about the intervention before and after it
was first used?
We picked this area to work in because the staff are very
conscientious about patient identification, so we knew we weren’t
putting any patients at risk, and they gave us really good feedback.
They were very willing because they did the new technology as well
as doing their regular checks to make sure that we had absolute
safety for the patients during the two weeks that we did these trials.
[The staff] were delighted. The receptionist said there were a
couple of patients that had just started the week that we were
doing the trial, and so they were there for five weeks. But in the
first couple of weeks it takes a little while to be able to recognise
them when they come up to the desk. On day two she was able
to recognise those patients – so the patients loved it because they
felt welcomed, and she loved it because she felt like a star because
she could actually recognise the patients.
These staff work with technology; that’s what they do for the
business. And I’m very open and willing to accommodate the
technology and found that it was very useful. So it was quite a
good outcome all around.
One of the concerns raised during the Q&A segment following
your presentation at the Digital Health Summit surrounded
patient confidentiality. How do you ensure that’s not a concern
for patients or their families?
There was a question around us collecting photos of patients for the
enrolment process. Part of the process the technology in radiation
oncology uses already collects a photo, so those patients are already
aware that their photo is going to be taken, and we have security
steps in place to make sure that we only use the photos for the right
things. They’re stored in the right way and there’s security around
who can access them. For the trial, we did actually put them onto
some software that we borrowed, and we deleted all of those when
we finished with the software that we used.
Privacy in hospitals is fairly well managed because we know many
private things about people that we’re used to keeping confidential.
What would you suggest to other healthcare providers who
might be interested in trialling similar technology in their
hospital?
I would say give it a go. We did a lot of review before we started,
and there’s a lot of literature out there supporting it. There’s a
lot of literature that’s also from the Australian Commission on
Safety and Quality in Health Care on using technology to help
make things safer. We seem to think that people are infallible and
systems make mistakes, but in actual fact, often people make
mistakes. And systems and processes can actually help safeguard
us against t hose. So it’s quite a safe thing to do. It does mean that
the enrolment process has to be really well organised and safe,
because you’re relying on the data that you get in enrolment.
Having said that, it’s probably not much different when you do
it manually – when it comes to the enrolment process, you still
need to get your facts right and concentrate on that. We were
delighted with the experience for patients, and if we can keep
patients safe and give them a good experience, then I think it’s
worth everybody having a look at it. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 27