workforce
needs, the nurses were having trouble driving home because they
were sleepy, they made mistakes because they were sleepy, and
of course, they were trying to juggle work, have a family life, do
social things. It’s a very difficult situation.
I believe one of the findings of your research was that the
chance of a clinician making an error can increase by 36 per
cent after working 12-hour shifts on consecutive days.
Yes, and most people do work consecutive days. They’ve seen this
in other industries, like with factory workers. After 8–12 hours, the
risk of an injury and fatality goes way up. Truck drivers after 10–12
hours on the road are more likely to have an accident.
Our bodies are not designed to do precise work for long
periods. We need our break, we need our sleep, but the demands
of the job sometimes reduce our ability to do that.
You also found that if a nurse has 10 hours off in between
shifts, they’ll only sleep about five hours.
Some hospitals are beginning to experiment with an alternative
approach and saying, “If this is your lunch break, you can take a 15 or
20-minute nap. It might help you.”
Of course, you’d have to get the lunch break to start with,
and sometimes that doesn’t happen in nursing because of the
staff shortages.
As well as avoiding caffeine – so you can use it when you need
it – you could stay in the nurse’s station, which should have
bright lights. In other industries, you can put bright lights in the
workroom, but you don’t want to put bright lights in a patient’s
room at night. Bright lights could increase your alertness, but
On occasion, nurses were working
23 hours and 55 minutes. They
weren’t getting any longer breaks than
somebody working eight or 12 hours.
Right. Some of the time-use studies the US has done have
found that this is pretty much true of any industry. If you’ve got
16 hours between the shifts, you’ll use eight hours to get sleep,
but if you only have 10 hours, you only get to have five hours of
sleep because you’ve got to drive to and from work, you have
to prepare food, you might want to do something with your
children. There are many other demands. only if you’re sitting at a desk charting. Caring for a patient, you’re
going to be in the room, and you’re going to try and keep it dim
so you don’t wake them up.
You’ve made some recommendations, and one which would
hurt me if I were a nurse is to avoid caffeine. In your paper, were there any other shocking areas that came
to light that you didn’t think you would encounter?
We encourage people to avoid caffeine so that when you need the
alerting effect of caffeine, you’ll get it. If you’re used to consuming
caffeine, like most of us, and you drink another cup of coffee or
tea, it doesn’t really do anything. But, if you’re not used to it, then it
will really alert you – as well as a short nap. I think just how many hours the nurses were working. As I said,
a few of them worked as long as 23 hours and 55 minutes. We
had nurses who were picking up so many shifts a week that they
were working 80 and 90 hours, which our medical students and
residents were recently forbidden to do.
Maybe it was economic, but whatever the reason, that’s a lot
of work hours and very little downtime. Of course, the number
of hours you worked a week affected your risk of making an
error. Fortunately, at the time we did research in Australia, more
nurses were working part-time and were not working as many
hours as they were in the US. What I understand is 12-hour shifts
are becoming more common here, and I’m guessing that the
distances you have to travel between places might be a factor too
in getting home. ■
What other ways would you recommend we combat this?
Well, I know in Australia you have a duty of care both on the
employer’s side and the employee’s. The employer should
not be working nurses so long that it endangers them or their
patients. The employees should also get enough sleep.
However, at least in the US, even on your lunch break, you’re
forbidden to leave the campus of the hospital – you’re not allowed
to sleep even though you’re not being paid for this time.
The study authors recommend avoiding regular
caffeine – so it works when you really need it.
nursingreview.com.au | 31