workforce
Dead tired
A sleep deprivation expert
talks nurse fatigue and its
effects on patient safety.
Ann Rogers interviewed
by Conor Burke
H
ow many hours do you work a day, and how much sleep
do you think you get a night?
According to Dr Ann Rogers, it probably isn’t enough.
And if that’s the case, your patients are at risk. Studies have shown
that the likelihood of a clinician making an error can increase by
36 per cent after working 12-hour shifts on consecutive days.
Fatigue can manifest itself in a number of ways. Forgetfulness,
poor decision making, slowed reaction times, reduced vigilance or
bad moods, and the obvious nodding off.
An internationally renowned expert in sleep deprivation, Rogers
is in Australia to present a paper titled ‘Staff Nurse Fatigue and
Patient Safety’ at a public seminar hosted by the Charles Darwin
University College of Nursing and Midwifery.
“Everybody needs to be conscious – not having enough sleep
affects the nurse’s health, it affects patient safety, but it also affects
the health of the community,” Rogers said. “Because a tired worker
driving home can be very dangerous if they’re trying to stay awake.”
Rogers told Nursing Review about a study that showed
a 3.4 per cent probability of an error when a nurse had less than six
hours sleep at night. In a hospital with 1000 nursing shifts per day,
this would translate to a probability of 34 errors per day.
Rogers said nurses need to ensure they get 7–8 hours of sleep
a night, and that hospital policies need to ensure nurses get their
breaks and are allowed to sleep during their breaks if need be.
30 | nursingreview.com.au
Nursing Review spoke with Rogers ahead of her talk to discuss
nurse fatigue and its consequences.
NR: It seems to me that it’s a given that tired people make
mistakes, and it’s also a given that nurses work long hours.
Has there been much research on these two areas?
AR: There hadn’t been until my research in the early 2000s. We’d
done a lot of research in the US on the long work hours associated
with physicians, but nurses in the US are the largest group of
healthcare providers and we’ve not looked at them. Everybody
assumed they worked eight hours, that they went home at the
end of the shift. But we found that most of them were not working
eight hours, they were working 12-hour shifts, and they were not
going home at the end of the shift, they had to finish up. We did a
small study here at the University of South Australia, and we found
that most nurses were going home at the end of their shifts in the
Adelaide area, but they were still tired.
Tell us about your recent paper. What were your major
findings and who did you survey?
We surveyed 900 nurses in the US, which unfortunately was not
that recent. I’d like to replicate the survey, but the funding isn’t
there. We did find that the nurses who work 12-hour shifts or
longer were 2–3 times more likely to make an error. Most of the
errors were very minor, but they can add up.
We were quite shocked that some of our hospital staff nurses –
not midwives nor other nurses – were being scheduled for shifts
as long as 20 hours. On occasion, they were working 23 hours
and 55 minutes. They weren’t getting any longer breaks than
somebody working eight or 12 hours.
Like Australia, we have a nursing shortage – actually, in most
parts of the world there’s a nursing shortage – so people were
working extra shifts or long shifts. While it meets patient care