clinical practice
Also, for some patients, they actually
liked the interaction of an open ward
and having conversations with the other
patients and to see staff interacting. So,
there’s a potential for patients to feel
isolated in a single room.
From the international examples, did
you find anything about the health
benefits of the patients outweighing
the costs?
No, there’s actually very little in this area.
Certainly there wasn’t anything that we saw
in the international literature.
Our study looked at preparing for a move
to all single rooms, so it asked nurses and
patients what they thought would change
from the current environment – which is a
mixture of six and four-bay wards.
The nursing staff we interviewed echoed
the concerns we found in the international
literature. They saw the advantages as
very much for the patients, especially in
terms of confidentiality and improved sleep
– it’d be quieter for patients and would
improve privacy.
However, they also saw disadvantages:
the increased walking distance and,
depending on the design of the building,
the lack of opportunity to constantly
observe patients and for the patients to
see them. That was their big concern: the
patients’ safety.
The patients said they thought it would
be quieter, but they also shared the same
concern as the nurses: they wouldn’t get
to see what was happening on the wards,
they wouldn’t be able to watch people walk
past, and they wouldn’t be able to have a
casual conversation with people. So there
was some concern about the isolation
and not being continually observed by the
nursing staff.
patients who may be confused or who are
very unwell, where the nurses want to be
able to observe them continuously, which
a single room environment wouldn’t allow.
Are there examples of hospitals that
currently employ the single room
environment?
Absolutely. There is a move to this in
England. One of the sites surveyed by a
colleague of ours, Jill Maven, who’s on the
research team, was Tunbridge Wells, which
moved to an all single room environment.
I also have some colleagues I work with in
Denmark and they’re just rebuilding a new
hospital there, and it’s going to be an all
single room environment too.
But nothing in Australia so far?
I think this hospital that’s just opened up
[the Royal Adelaide Hospital] is the first
government, all single room hospital.
Private hospitals do have single rooms,
however.
As you mentioned, nurses’ voices are
critical to inform design going forward.
Is that likely in the design or upgrade of
hospitals and wards? Do designers of
hospitals consult nurses?
Again, I can’t talk to whether that actually
happens, but what we’re saying is that they
absolutely must talk to nurses. It’s really
important that nurses are sitting at the
table and have an important say in how
buildings are designed – particularly if you
do move to all single rooms – how they
build in that line of sight so nurses can see
patients at all times, as well as allow privacy
for patients. What our paper is saying is that
the nurses must be at the table.
Is there anything you’d like to add?
I’d just like to acknowledge the Australian
Nursing and Midwifery Federation. The
South Australian branch funded this
research and I think it was a very important
research to fund.
We’re hoping to repeat the study in
that new environment to see whether the
nurses’ and patients’ predictions come true
or whether their concerns are managed.
We’re looking forward to the next stage of
this study. ■
One advantage of multi-bed rooms is they allow nurses to monitor many patients at once.
Did you conclude that single room
occupancy is something that should be
explored here?
There was some caution around making
sure that in moving to an all single room
environment, nurses were involved in the
process of change and in thinking about
how they would have to work differently,
such as increased patient rounding –
that is, going around on a regular basis
during their shift to observe and talk to
patients and make sure everyone’s okay.
So they’re certainly having to think about
doing things differently.
I think there remain some concerns that
an all single room environment perhaps
may not be the best, particularly for those
nursingreview.com.au | 21