clinical practice
A room of one’s own
Should we move to single
occupancy hospital rooms?
Lynette Cusack interviewed
by Conor Burke
Q
uiet and private, or isolated and
hard to manage? These are
the flipsides in the increasing
argument for and against single occupancy
hospital rooms.
There is a growing trend internationally
for single occupancy rooms, but the dearth
of literature in the area means its benefits
remain to be seen.
Advocates believe that single patient
rooms increase privacy and confidentiality.
They can also avoid gender bed blocking
and, importantly, have the potential to
better control infections.
Writing in the BMJ, Hugh Pennington,
emeritus professor of bacteriology at the
University of Aberdeen, cites a Canadian
study that shows a 40 per cent reduction in
20 | nursingreview.com.au
some strains of bacteria, like golden staph,
when changing intensive care wards from
multi-bed to single rooms.
Patients were also found to have 10 per
cent shorter stays.
However, those against the move believe
that patients are against single rooms.
Patient loneliness is a problem, and there
is also a worry that a nurses’ overview of
patients and ability to treat them in a hurry
could be made more difficult.
In an Australian context, evidence is
also hard to find. Currently, the new Royal
Adelaide Hospital is the only government
facility with 100 per cent single occupancy.
Lynette Cusack, associate professor
of nursing at the University of Adelaide,
and her colleagues have conducted
some research into the advantages and
disadvantages for patients and nurses
of single rooms.
Nursing Review spoke with Cusack
to learn more.
NR: What does the international
literature say about 100 per cent single
room occupancy?
LC: It appears to be the trend for more
hospitals to be built as all single room
capacity. We had the opportunity to
look at the literature: there isn’t much
written about this topic, but we did find
comments about both the advantages and
disadvantages for nurses and patients.
In your study of Australian hospitals,
what were your predictions for the
benefits of single occupancy?
The literature was saying that the
advantage is very much for the patients.
They have control of the environment
such as noise, light and temperature,
and it can help to improve sleep. There’s
more privacy, more opportunity to have
confidential discussions in single rooms,
and also more space for visitors, who may
perhaps spend more time with a patient in
a private environment.
For nurses, some of the advantages were
fewer patient transfers – so that means not
having to move the beds around as much
– and there is the potential for reduced
medication errors.
I assume there were also disadvantages.
Certainly. What the previous literature was
saying is that the main disadvantage for
nursing staff was increased travelling time.
So that means the walking distance they
have to cover on each shift is increased.
There was also concern raised about
the isolation of patients. So in the open
bay or open ward system, the nurses can
see the patients and the patients can see
the nursing staff. But in an all single room
environment, there was the risk that nurses
may lose sight of the patient, so they’re
not able to identify quickly if the patient’s
condition is deteriorating.