specialty focus
Way back in Florence Nightingale’s day in the 18th century,
nursing became a gendered profession, and so men in
nursing were excluded at that time and females took over
the ranks of nursing. From then on, it’s become a very heavily
gendered profession.
So, what we see in hospital dramas is that not only is there
conflict between nurses and doctors, it is often a gendered
conflict. Even though these days more than 50 per cent of doctors
are female, in nursing it’s still the case that 90 per cent are female.
It’s a context of working practice that foregrounds
gender and the troubles between the sexes. Would you
say that’s part of it?
DB: Yes, and also that in any kind of storytelling, stereotypes
actually work. They work as a kind of shorthand. When writers
use this idea of the handsome, all-knowing male doctor and
the attractive, submissive, helpful female nurse, it’s very easy for
writers to plug into those stereotypes because, of course, they
also have other things to talk about [and don’t want to waste time
setting up complex personalities].
Most of these stories are not totally about nurses or doctors
and how they relate, or how they’re seen in society, but some
other drama or comedy or other thing going on. And so these
stereotypes, which of course in other professions too are male
and female, are just easy to plug into. Viewers know what they are
seeing, and so the drama or comedy unfolds [without needing too
much set-up].
You talk about the stereotype of endlessly caring sex objects,
but there often isn’t a middle ground. They are often portrayed
too far on side or the other – as malevolent, dangerous,
or out of control, to paraphrase you both. Why does it go to
such extremes?
DB: That goes to the heart of good storytelling. In our work on
these representations, we’re not saying that these representations
aren’t entertaining, or good storytelling, or fantastic
entertainment. When you have an idea of nurses in society as
good – and research says people trust nurses more than virtually
any other figure in society – if you can then turn around that
goodness into badness, that’s very entertaining for viewers.
MM: There has always been goodies and baddies. It’s an ancient
part of storytelling to have a protagonist and an antagonist. But
what we’re saying is that the danger in having these two extremes
is that the nuances in between get left out.
What we also argue is that pop culture is not insignificant. It has
the power to persuade people that what they see on screen is
what happens in reality.
We would argue that reality is far more complex and nuanced.
The idea of the good nurse – endlessly caring, always empathic
– who has lots of patience and lots of time to sit there and calm
the fevered brow, and, on the other side, the bad nurse, who is
strategic and has evil in her heart and murder on her mind, is rarely
the reality in nursing, which is a very diverse profession.
Yet, in popular culture, that diversity in the work is not apparent.
It’s not made visible, and that does the public a disservice because
nobody actually really knows the complexity of nursing work.
DB: That then becomes a problem when you’re recruiting
for the industry, because some of the very nurses of the future
are absorbing these stereotypes. That is therefore affecting
their choice of career and how they fare once they go into
the profession.
You mentioned the nuance in between, and in your paper you
refer to many different shows and nurses. A show that I liked,
with an actress I liked, was Nurse Jackie, which is about a nurse
who has a drug addiction but who is also a very capable at her
job. You almost it hold up as an example of one of the more
well-rounded portrayals.
MM: Nurse Jackie deals with more than just her personal issues.
All the storylines in the series deal with complex parts of reality,
such as domestic violence, people dying and suffering alone,
people too poor to pay for their insurance. All of these issues are
raised in Nurse Jackie because it is a satirical show, so it has a
licence, I guess, to deal with the problematic.
Another show that does something similar is the British
television series Getting On, which is another view of nursing as
being very hard work. Often it’s the working class who work in
nursing, and they have to put up with all sorts of bureaucratic
policies that slow care down and interfere with the relationships
that could be happening between nurses and patients.
Yes, with Nurse Jackie we are seeing a nurse that is not exactly
balanced, and she certainly crosses ethical boundaries, but it also
allows for other storylines to flow and therefore it’s intriguing and
challenging for the audience.
DB: Interestingly too, both of these series show that the
hospital itself is not a perfect place. They show staff shortages,
bureaucracies interfering with the real work that needs to go on,
people with different skill sets, and so on. So even though they
may not seem to, they actually offer some deep comment on the
healthcare system.
What can the media and wider society do to remedy these
perceptions in popular culture?
MM: I think Nurse Jackie and Getting On have done a lot for
encouraging writers, producers and long-form series to create
more complex characters with really compelling stories.
Over the weekend I watched a new series on Netflix called
Dirty John, which is a true story about a male nurse who goes
to great lengths to con people and is able to do so because of
his access to knowledge and resources as a nurse. The story is
What we see in hospital dramas is that
not only is there conflict between nurses and
doctors, it is often a gendered conflict.
compelling. I think the public are now ready for complex stories
about protagonists who are not just rendered as sex objects or
corollaries to stories, but play a central role.
DB: I think too that our role is not just to criticise certain
portrayals, but to look at them and say, “Wow, I really enjoyed that
little half-hour comedy, but what was this saying about nurses,
and what does that mean for how nurses are seen and how they
see themselves?”
We need to look at these films, books, stories and TV series,
and then say as scholars, teachers or the media: How can we talk
about them?
The goodie/baddie discussion of ‘Well, here’s a nurse and she’s
evil and that’s good for nursing’ is very limited. However, asking
‘Why is the public fascinated by this nasty nurse?’ is a much more
interesting conversation for us all to have. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 17