specialty focus
Edie Falco as Jackie Peyton in Nurse Jackie.
Angel of mercy or sex object?
How fictional stereotypes influence
nurses and patients.
Donna Lee Brien and Margaret McAllister
interviewed by Conor Burke
N
obody knows you’re here. And you better hope nothing
happens to me. Because if I die ... you die,” Annie Wilkes
tells injured writer Paul Sheldon in Stephen King’s Misery.
Sheldon had crashed his car in a blizzard and Wilkes found him.
She’s his number one fan – and an ex-nurse. She’s also a psychotic
killer who holds Sheldon hostage and tortures him.
This is just one of the many wild representations of nurses in
popular culture that range from the endlessly giving angels to the
evil baddies, like Wilkes and the infamous Nurse Ratched from One
Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest.
They can also encompass the ridiculous, like the nervous and
clumsy Gaylord Focker in Meet the Parents, the troubled but
more realistic lead character in Nurse Jackie, or the all-knowing,
sassy Carla from Scrubs. But these portrayals can have an effect
on real-life nurses.
Donna Lee Brien, a professor of creative industries at Central
Queensland University, and Margaret McAllister, a professor of
nursing at the same university, have studied popular culture’s
limited view of nurses and found that it can take its toll.
“To portray nurses as endlessly caring is verging on saying
that it’s an inherent trait that a person has within them, and that
16 | nursingreview.com.au
therefore makes them a good nurse, but in fact it will likely make
them a very vulnerable nurse who will be traumatised and burnt
out,” McAllister told Nursing Review.
“People are constantly disappointed that nurses don’t have the
time to stay with someone in their pain or tearfulness – and that
hurts two sets of people: it hurts the patient, and it also hurts the
nurses,” McAllister said.
Brien thinks that newly graduated nurses are particularly
susceptible to the unrealistic stereotypes of nurses presented
by the media.
“I don’t think it’s helping our new nurses that are coming into
education and then going out into nursing to also expect that
of themselves, because they’re going to get hurt and frustrated,”
she said.
McAllister and Brien see sexism as partly to blame for these
perceptions. However, nurses in media can also provide
commentary on class, knowledge and power between doctors
and nurses, as well as the economics of healthcare.
“It’s a class thing, and it’s a power struggle between medical
knowledge and nursing knowledge,” McAllister said.
“For example, Nurse Jackie and Getting On are stories that are
critical of economic rationalism, health policies and the austerity
measures that have made, for example, the NHS in England run on
skeleton staff. It’s a comment on economics and politics as much
as it is on workers within a system,” she said.
Nursing Review spoke to Brien and McAllister to unfold this issue.
NR: You wrote an essay recently for The Conversation about
nurses in pop culture. They’re often portrayed as subordinate
or endlessly caring sex objects. Why and where did this start?
MM: Hospital dramas make for great stories because there’s
conflict, there’s intrigue, there’s expertise in the face of suffering
and questions in need. So, for a start, hospital stories are
compelling, and to make hospital stories even more dramatic
there needs to be some kind of interaction between the sexes.
Nurses and doctors make for that intriguing interaction.