Legal corner
“It is clear that the alleged damages do not relate to a physical or
recognised psychiatric illness. In essence, the damages consist of
[Dr P’s] emotional upset, broken dreams, possible disruption to his
lifestyle and career, and a potential reduction in future earnings,
all of which are said to flow f rom the birth of a child he did not
want. Although the claim is not for the direct costs associated with
raising the child, all of the damages claimed by the appellant are
the result of consequences flowing from the unwanted birth of a
child, albeit unwanted only by the father.”
Dr P’s $4 million law suit was dismissed on appeal. The appeal
was refused on several grounds, including:
“It would be contrary to the spirit, purpose and policy reflected
in [the] no-fault child support regime to view parents as equally
responsible for maintaining a child but, at the same time, to
allow recovery by the appellant against the mother for the loss
purportedly suffered by him as a result of that responsibility, which
loss would presumably increase as he devotes more of his time
and resources to the child’s upbringing.”
Battery against D was also alleged. That is, Dr P tried to prove
on the balance of probabilities that D intentionally touched him in
a sexual manner and that interference with his body was ‘harmful’
or ‘offensive’. The law was that this element is implied (assuming a
lack of consent) in the context of a sexual battery.
The court dismissed this argument. The court noted that Dr
P was not exposed to any serious transmissible disease or other
significant risk of serious bodily harm flowing from the intimate
encounters. The court went on to state:
“The alleged deception in this case was not with respect to
the nature of the act, but only as to the likely consequences
flowing therefrom. The sexual contact in this case was consented
to and there were no physically injurious consequences. There
was therefore no violation of [Dr P’s] right to physical or sexual
autonomy that would give rise to a claim in battery.”
With surely the development of male birth control measures in
the future, the court made an interesting comment in relation to
the difference between the physical effects of pregnancy between
a male and a female, in the context of damages suffered from acts
of deceit leading to a pregnancy:
“[Dr P’s] alleged damage is principally emotional harm or, in other
words, hurt feelings and lost aspirations and/or career opportunities
flowing from the birth of his child. His situation, as a man, is quite
different from that of the woman. Clearly, there are profound physical
and psychological effects on a mother undergoing a pregnancy that
do not apply to the father of the child.”
Should a future case arise where the facts are reversed, one
could say it is an area of litigation worthy of the saying, ‘Watch
this space!’ ■
Scott Trueman is a lecturer in the School of Nursing, Midwifery
and Nutrition at James Cook University.
Hamilton Victoria, Heart of the Western District
Combine a challenging career with a peaceful lifestyle!
Located between the mountains and the sea, Hamilton offers an enviable and affordable lifestyle,
stress-free commuting and stunning scenery around every corner.
Manager Community Nursing Services
Classification ZE6 - $91k plus super | Permanent Full Time - 80hrs per fortnight with ADO
Are you looking for a role where:
• Your passion for high quality health care and management excellence can flourish
• You get a real chance to be mentored into a senior management role
• You will flourish with support for additional post graduate education
• You have a real opportunity to contribute to better health outcomes in your community
This exciting opportunity to contribute to excellence in primary and preventative health with a focus on health promotion,
patient centred care, innovation and clinical excellence in a thriving regional city may be just the role for you. For further
information contact Morven Gemmill, Director of Primary & Preventative Health on 03 5551 8573
If you want to transform your career please visit our website www.wdhs.net
Western District Health Services is an Equal Opportunity Employer and encourages Indigenous and Torres Strait Islander people to apply.
nursingreview.com.au | 23