Legal corner
Law offers no
protection
A man sues his partner
after she falls pregnant and
gives birth, alleging she lied
about her contraception.
By Scott Trueman
T
he birth of a child is usually a joyous occasion for both
parents. But what if the father did not plan for the partner
to become pregnant and relied on her assurances
regarding birth control, which turned out to be wrong or
misleading? What legal recourse does he have?
In a recent decision of the Court of Appeal in Canada, a male
plaintiff (Dr P), a medical practitioner, brought a civil action for
fraud, deceit, fraudulent misrepresentation and battery against a
female defendant (D).
He claimed damages that the deception deprived him of the
benefit of choosing when and with whom he would assume the
responsibility of fatherhood.
Dr P, it was stated, “wanted to meet a woman, fall in love, get
married, enjoy his life as a husband with his wife and then, when
he and his wife thought the time was ‘right’, to have a baby”.
He pleaded that he consented to intimate relations with D on
the understanding that she was using effective contraception. In
his view, this was an express or implied misrepresentation and his
consent was vitiated, having been obtained through deception
and dishonesty.
The facts at trial were that the couple began dating on May
14, 2014. Three days later, on a second date, they retired to D’s
apartment where they engaged in intimate relations, during which
22 | nursingreview.com.au
Dr P asked D whether she had any condoms. When she replied
that she did not, he asked if she was ‘on the pill’, to which she
said yes. After accepting this assurance Dr P consented to further
intimacy. They went on four more dates in the following three
weeks. On each occasion, they engaged in consensual intimacy.
On each occasion, D did not say or do anything to suggest she
was not, or was no longer, on the pill.
On June 10, 2014, prior to another intimate encounter, they
discussed their practice of not using a condom. Dr P advised D
that he would happily wear one and that he did not want her to
feel uncomfortable. D stated that she preferred relations without
a condom. Again, D did not say or do anything to suggest that her
prior representations were not, or were no longer, true.
Two more dates in June resulted in the same pattern of
intimacy. By July, the pair decided to end their intimate
relationship but agreed to remain friends. During the following
weeks, they contacted one another several times by text message
with respect to inconsequential matters, but D did disclose that
she was pregnant and that Dr P was the father.
Dr P sued and asserted that, on the basis of D’s knowingly false
representations with respect to her lack of birth control and her
implied intention not to conceive or deliver a child, he engaged in
intimacy that resulted in the birth of a child.
He alleged that his consent was vitiated, having been induced
by D’s misrepresentations that led him to believe she was taking
the birth control pill as prescribed and directed.
As the child’s father, Dr P asserted that he had suffered
damages. He claimed he had been deprived of the benefit of
choice with respect to when, and with whom, he would conceive
a child and raise a family.
The court summarised Dr P’s case “as a tort claim for
involuntary parenthood made by one parent against the other”.