industry & reform
environment with nothing disturbing it.
But the other important point here is you
don’t have midwives appearing in a pair of
sandals and an incense stick. Those midwives
arrive with equipment to resuscitate. They
have drugs to stop bleeding. They have
an incredible amount of skill in managing
emergencies, and if that woman needs
to be transferred to hospital, they call
an ambulance.
It’s not an either/or. It’s about the right
woman in the right place with the right
person at the right time. If we could get
that balance right in our system, we would
have much safer and more satisfying births
for women.
Are homebirths beneficial for the health
system from a cost perspective?
Oh, definitely. The large Birthplace in
Australia study is concluding at the moment.
It’s being led by Professor Caroline Homer
at UTS. The publication will come out soon
looking, Australia-wide, at outcomes, costs
and everything else.
However, there’s no doubt that homebirth
is significantly less costly for several reasons.
These women stay in their own homes.
They stay in their own bed. They eat their
own food. They get fewer infections. Their
babies have fewer issues because they’re
kept with their mothers. The whole snowball
effect of cost that occurs in our hospital
system is completely negated. Plus, very
little equipment is needed when you have a
normal physiological birth.
Caesarean sections, on the other hand,
cost a huge amount of money in extra
days of stay, in extra equipment, in extra
morbidity. They also affect subsequent
pregnancies. Only about 12 per cent of
women in Australia will have a vaginal birth
after first having a caesarean. So every
caesarean breeds more caesareans.
So homebirths are definitely much more
cost effective, but it’s not just about cost –
it’s a very safe option for mothers and babies
when women are low-risk and you have
competent midwives in place.
Also, it’s an important factor in reducing
PTSD and trauma from birth, which we now
know is rising in the Western world. Some
studies show that about one in 10 women
experience PTSD after giving birth. That’s
not a great way to start motherhood. It’s not
going to be a good influence on the mother-
baby bond or the development of the child.
What has to happen for homebirth to
become more mainstream?
The first step is, if you look at the Royal
Australian and New Zealand College of
Obstetricians and Gynaecologists policy on
homebirth, it basically says that it’s dreadful
and don’t do it, and it’s very dangerous. They
base their recommendation on one very
highly criticised and now debunked US study,
because that’s the one that they handpicked
to support their belief system.
The UK has a wonderful joint statement
between the obstetricians and midwives that
says homebirth is great for low-risk women.
They have a national government guideline
that says, if you’re low-risk, then homebirth
probably gives you more advantage, so they
recommend it.
In Canada, you’ve got the obstetricians and
midwives again saying homebirth should be
supported. Go to the US, and they say, “Oh,
no, no. Homebirth is very dangerous.”
So, we’ve got to get over the philosophical
and ideological divide between the
professions. That doesn’t help.
Women are going to homebirth.
Unfortunately, in Australia – and a lot of our
research is now looking at this – a lot of
women are choosing to do it themselves. So,
they will have a baby with no professional
in attendance, or they will have a doula or a
birth worker who’s not professionally trained.
They’re doing it because they can’t access
midwives, because they can’t afford to pay
for private midwives, because there are not
enough homebirth programs.
So, we’re creating fewer safe situations by
putting our head in the sand, and it’s time we
all got together and said, “This is when it’s
safe. This is when it’s not. Let’s give women
evidence-based information. Let’s support
choice. Let’s get over our ideological divide.”
Scientific evidence and government
recommendations support homebirth for
low-risk women. It’s really the obstetrics
community that continues to have enormous
fears about it. Partly, I can understand that. If
you’re an obstetrician, and your job is only to
deal with problems, of course, in your mind,
birth is always a problem. But we’ve got to
keep in perspective that birth can actually go
very well. Midwives are the experts at caring
for women having normal physiological
labour. Let’s both do our jobs where our
expertise lies. Let’s support each other and
not continue this divide. ■
Avondale’s Master of Nursing is designed to extend
and deepen a registered nurse’s knowledge, skills and
appreciation of advanced practice within complex
health care environments. Students are given the
choice to develop nursing specialist qualifications in
either Clinical Nursing, Clinical Teaching or Leadership
and Management.
Mode: Distance education (Online)
APPLY NOW FOR 2019
for February and August intakes.
To find out more about our courses or to apply online
visit www.avondale.edu.au/nursing
phone +61 2 4980 2377 or
email study@avondale.edu.au
Avondale College Ltd trading as Avondale College of Higher Education
CRICOS Provider No: 02731D | TEQSA: PRV12015 | ABN: 53 108 186 401
nursingreview.com.au | 13