industry & reform
Bring it on home
Homebirths
often safer,
study shows.
Hannah Dahlen
interviewed by
Conor Burke
T
he Royal Hospital for Women
in Randwick, NSW, is offering a
homebirth option for low-risk
pregnancies. One of only 14 public hospitals
across the country currently doing so, the
new scheme provides the support of two
experienced midwives at no cost, an option
normally only available privately.
Contrary to popular opinion, recent
research suggests that in the case of low-
risk pregnancies, homebirths are safer, and
that women planning hospital births show
“statistically significantly lower odds of
normal vaginal birth than in other planned
settings” (Midwifery 62 (2018) 240–255).
“Women experienced severe perineal
trauma or haemorrhage at a lower rate in
planned homebirths than in obstetric units,”
the authors wrote.
This research has implications for
healthcare costs countrywide, and for a more
widespread rollout of the homebirth scheme.
Nursing Review spoke to one of the
study’s authors, Professor Hannah Dahlen,
of Western Sydney University’s School of
Nursing and Midwifery, to hear more about it.
NR: What is the thinking behind the Royal
Hospital’s free homebirth scheme?
HD: Around Australia, there are about
14 publicly funded homebirth programs
12 | nursingreview.com.au
attached to hospitals. They generally run out
of a hospital’s caseload midwifery program,
which is where midwives provide care to
women throughout the pregnancy. They’re
on call for your birth, and they do your
postnatal care. That program is offered to
women around Australia. Probably about
9–10 per cent of women are now able
to access that. We know that the highest
scientific evidence supports this as the best
birth option for women.
A team I’ve been involved with published a
systematic review meta-analysis looking at all
the literature on the safety of homebirths. We
looked at over 28 articles for low-risk women
who were having babies at home. We looked
at things like morbidity and mortality for
the baby and the mother. We compared
low-risk women planning a homebirth with
low-risk women planning a birth in a hospital
or birthing centre. We found no difference
in the number of babies dying by planned
place of birth.
However, we found much higher rates of
normal births at home, like more than three
times the rate of normal birth. We also found
that women had less severe perineal trauma
at home, less haemorrhage at home, and
their babies were less likely to be admitted
into a neonatal intensive care unit.
So what homebirth offers now, with
all the evidence we have, is a real option
for women who are low-risk, who are
attended by competent midwives, and
who are well networked into a responsive
system. We know that women have a lot
less intervention, that satisfaction is really
high, and that it’s equally safe for the baby,
as long as you are careful that the woman is
low-risk, the midwives are competent, and a
responsive system is in place.
If you look at the Randwick program, you
have that in place: experienced midwives
who work in caseload and are across all
areas of the childbirth continuum; a fantastic
hospital with supportive obstetricians and a
supportive management; and you have the
ability to bring women into a system that will
do what’s best for them.
That is the ideal, because one of the
worst scenarios we have in the homebirth
situation, which unfortunately goes on too
much, is a real hostility towards women
who have a homebirth. If they’re transferred
in, sometimes those midwives are treated
like absolutely crap, not to mention the
way the women are treated. That’s really
unsafe, because it makes women reluctant
to go in. It makes midwives nervous about
transferring.
In summary, the scientific evidence is
now clear that if you are low-risk and have
a competent midwife, or midwives, in
your home, and a good system in place,
homebirth is as safe physically for the
mother and the baby. And it’s actually safer
in many terms, regarding higher normal birth
satisfaction and breast feeding, skin-to-skin,
and a whole lot of other factors that are a
huge benefit that you don’t necessarily get
in hospital.
Do you think clinicians in Australian
believe hospital births are always safer?
I think Australia has a very conservative,
medicalised approach to birth. We have one
of the highest caesarean rates in the world:
one in three women have major abdominal
surgery to have a baby. Look at countries like
the Netherlands, where 15–20 per cent of
babies are born at home, and the caesarean
rate sits at about 15 per cent – half of ours.
Homebirth is normal in that culture. You only
go to hospital if there’s a problem. You stay
home if everything’s normal.
Australia has a very medicalised approach.
This attitude doesn’t appear in many other
countries. In New Zealand, for example,
5 per cent of babies are born at home. In the
UK, in some places, more than 10 per cent of
babies are born at home.
What a lot of people don’t realise, and
this is something that’s really important,
is we create a lot of problems by what
we do to women in hospital. When we
intervene unnecessarily, we start a cascade
of intervention. To intervene when you don’t
need to, which is often going on in hospital,
you create more risk of things like bleeding
emergencies. You’re not getting that risk at
home. You’re having low-risk women who
are having minimal intervention done, who
are birthing and labouring in a physiological