industry & reform
that suffering. And you may be aware that the government’s
JobKeeper program and some of the other interventions that have
been taken are historically very large forms of income support.
The JobKeeper program, which is something like $130 billion
over six months, is by far the biggest single expenditure that the
Commonwealth government has ever undertaken in a six-month
period, over any single program.
I don’t think it’s perfect. I think that there are gaps where
we could do better. I worry about the gap in support for the
short-term casuals and some other things that I think could be
improved. But by and large, these are very large interventions that
are being taken, precisely because we should understand how
much suffering is involved.
What Gigi was getting at was a number of additional concerns.
Think about not just the notional economic costs, like lost wages
or lost incomes that people have, or lost jobs that they have in
a recession, but also all of the broader notions of wellbeing that
also begin to go south, like mental health, increases in domestic
violence. All of these things also tend to be worse in recessions.
If you think about attaching some kind of value to that, then you
might hypothetically imagine saying that we’ve perhaps gone
too far. You could do a cost benefit analysis, where you take into
account those broader notions of wellbeing.
I think the problem with that is that you have to be very careful
to have a sort of a principled notion of what you’re going to
include and what you’re not going to include in that kind of cost
benefit analysis. For example, on one side, we have much less
pollution. We have many fewer traffic accidents. We have all of
these other things that are also antecedents of the shutdown in
economic activity.
Personally, as an economist, I prefer to have a fairly narrow
economic calculation: let’s just talk about economic costs and
benefits in a quite narrow sense, but then understand that we live
in a human society, and that is only part of the calculation. But
let me at least know in a very transparent, very clear way what
that economic calculation is as one input into a larger ethical
conversation of which it can only ever be part of.
I’d rather that, than attempting to – in a somewhat opaque
way – insert ethical considerations into what purports to be an
economic calculation. Why mental health, but not air pollution, to
use that earlier example?
Other economists have suggested that maybe we have to let
it run rampant and put up with the deaths for the good of the
economy. Do they teach morals and ethics in economics?
No, they do not. In a conversation on the same topic with an
economist friend of mine, I reminded him that there are two
famous books that Adam Smith wrote. There’s The Wealth of
Nations and The Theory of Moral Sentiments. They’re very
different books.
One is purely a book of economics and the other is purely a
book of moral philosophy, but the same person wrote them. I
think that’s a good model for economists to aspire to. We can
write narrow technical economic pieces and we can engage in
philosophy. As humans, we should be doing both, but it’s possible
to do technical economic work without being confused about
its standing as a piece of work. That’s just one part of a broader
discussion about what’s appropriate.
That argument that we should, in some sense, permit a certain
amount of death and illness for the good of the economy, I think is
just fundamental. Apart from being immoral in my view, because
of its implications for the treatment of other human beings, it’s
just technically wrong.
What those people have in mind is the ability to quarantine
those at high risk and to protect them as best as possible, while
the rest of us get on with our lives, because we’re low risk.
And the idea is that these things are kind of bound up together
because the people who are most exposed to the recession are
people who are younger with more unstable incomes.
From their point of view, you might think that these are
the people who most need to avail themselves of economic
opportunities. But the fact is that you cannot quarantine off the
high-risk people. For one thing, we don’t even know who all of
the high‐risk people are. My wife is high risk, but you wouldn’t
know it by looking at her. She’s not elderly. She just has another
acute condition that would make it high risk. There are many
people like that.
The idea that you quarantine some subset of the population
that are high risk, it doesn’t make sense. You couldn’t do it even if
you could identify the people, and even if you could identify them,
those people still mix with carers, they still have families, they still
have friends and there’s still going to be contact. So I don’t think
that argument really makes sense even on a technical front, let
alone a moral front.
It is quite a pervasive argument or discussion that’s going on,
because you and 250 of your fellow economists felt the need
to pen an open letter urging the government to put health
first. How did that come about?
Some people said to us that we were taking aim at a straw person,
and I feel like that was not quite right. In terms of actual decisionmaking
institutions right now, there’s not much pressure for a
rapid opening up of the economy. But we saw, especially the week
before last, a lot of opinion pieces online saying precisely this, that
we should open up much more quickly, that we’ve been hysterical,
we’ve overreacted, we’ve killed the economy and for no good
reason, so let’s get back on with it.
We were trying to say, no, that argument is mistaken. We cannot
take this for granted. We need to be very careful about this, and
that our best shot at protecting the economy over time is to make
sure we beat this thing properly. So, basically, to be patient.
We were really pushing back against people who were
cloaking themselves in economic arguments but basically aren’t
economists. They aren’t people with what I would consider
relevant expertise. They’re mostly journalists, columnists of
various kinds, but people who are clever, bright. I know some of
these people.
My colleagues and I wanted to make it clear that that view was a
fringe view. And although the people were cloaking themselves in
economic arguments, they didn’t really reflect what professional
economists believe about the situation, which has been, as far as I
can tell, almost exclusively supportive of the kind of analyses that
have been coming out of public health, and infectious disease
modelling more specifically.
There is a very clear consensus in Australia and other countries
that we should be beating the pandemic first, that this will be
best for the economy in the longer run. While that involves a lot
of suffering right now for many people, and I don’t discount that,
the correct way to deal with that suffering is through large income
support programs and things like that, rather than trying to be too
hasty on getting the economy back to normal, because that is a
very risky move. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 11