industry & reform
Ethics of the lockdown
An economist warns
against buying into fringe
views of pundits.
Chris Edmond interviewed
by Conor Burke
Over the past few weeks of lockdown and economic
turmoil, many commentators have spoken out, saying
the economic downturn is worse than the harm caused
by the outbreak. In other words, that the cure is worse than
the disease.
Nursing Review caught up with Chris Edmond, a professor
of economics from the University of Melbourne, to discuss the
idea further.
NR: What is your perception of the economy’s health?
CE: The economy is taking a tremendous hit. We are going to have
– by any of the usual measures – a lost economic output: lost
GDP or increased unemployment, reduced hours, any of the usual
measures. We’re going to have one of the biggest recessions that
we’ve seen since the Great Depression.
We’re still waiting to see exactly how bad it is by these measures.
But there’s no question that it is going to be very significant
– something the likes of which nobody living has any active
memory of. The people who last experienced an economy this
bad, by those conventional measures, were too young to have
participated in it.
Those conventional measures, however, don’t necessarily give
the full picture this time. This is very different to something like the
recession we had during the global financial crisis, where there
was essentially a kind of malfunctioning within certain specific
financial markets that then knocked on to the rest of the economy.
This is a recession that’s basically being engineered in order to
achieve public health goals.
The mere fact that output is falling, that people were unable to
work as many hours, that has significant implications. But it’s a
little bit hard to compare those numbers at face value to the sizes
of the declines that we’ve had in other recessions, because they’re
produced in a very different way and for a very different reason.
Engineering an economic shutdown was part of a larger objective,
which is achieving the social distancing restrictions that we need
in order to get the virus under control.
PwC reported that there’ll be a reduction of about $34 billion
in Australia’s GDP. Around the GFC, the cash balance was a
deficit of $27 billion. If this is all engineered, does that mean
we can engineer our way out easier?
That is the hope. Let’s take Australia, which currently is sitting
along with New Zealand in a relatively good place. We might be
thinking about relaxing some of the restrictions that we’ve had in
place, because we feel like we’ve got close to near eradication.
We’re maybe not quite there yet, but we’re getting close enough to
be seriously thinking about it.
What we would hope is that as we relax those restrictions, and
if we do so in a kind of careful, controlled way, we would get a
quicker return to normality than you would have assumed would
be true if all you were doing was looking at the size of the increase
in unemployment.
Typically when you have a big spike in unemployment, it takes a
very long time for that unemployment to come back down. When
you look at the spike in unemployment that the US had during the
financial crisis, those effects were very persistent.
We are having a big increase in unemployment right now, but
I think there are reasons to hope that the recovery will not be as
slow as the size of the shock would have led you to think.
But the size of the shock is so large that we should not view
that with rose-coloured glasses. Even if we had a quicker return to
normalcy, because we’d been moved so far away from normalcy,
we’re still going to be living with the economic consequences,
the pain and the suffering associated with this recession for quite
some time.
Gigi Foster, an economist, said on Q&A that ‘the cure is worse
than the disease’. Is there any benefit to this argument?
Let me just break this up into different pieces. There is no doubt
that this is a big recession, and all big recessions have to impose
tremendous suffering on people. But this is different. This is not a
recession because the central bank made a mistake or something
like that. This is a recession that was engineered to combat
the virus.
In this situation, we have to think about what the alternative was
to having these tough social distancing measures. The alternative
was not ‘no recession’ versus ‘tough social distancing’. The
alternative was to let the virus burn through the economy and have
a recession as people stopped going to restaurants and stopped
doing all the kinds of economic activity that they otherwise would
have done because they’re scared for their lives. It is a false choice
to think about it as economy versus health.
That said, definitely people are suffering. People like me should
be doing everything that we can to help find policies that alleviate
10 | nursingreview.com.au