workforce
I could see that students’ confidence
levels had been affected by their past
experiences with nurses and educators,
whether in the university or hospital
setting. I thought that if a student was
provided the opportunity to receive some
feedback, both positive and negative, about
their encounters with patients, they would
have the opportunity to not only act on
their faults, but also celebrate the positive
aspects of their communication skills.
Having good communication skills is
essential for nurses, and it is up to us, as
medical professionals and educators, to
foster not only their communication skills,
but also their confidence levels.
Tell us about the study itself. Who was
involved and what did they do?
I was assigned two supervisors from the
university to support my minor thesis
journey – Dr Angela Kucia and Mr Aaron
Farquharson. I recruited seven students
from the undergraduate Bachelor of
Nursing program at the University of South
Australia.
The data collection occurred over three
days on campus at the university. Each
participant attended separately. The role of
the patients in the scenarios were fulfilled
by my supervisors as well as by friends who
volunteered their time to act in the data
collection. Each participant attended for
approximately 30 minutes, and then no
further action was required from them.
During the data collection process, I
watched the participants as they undertook
the first scenario and made personal notes
on their words, actions and behaviours
when interacting with the ‘patients’.
After the scenario was complete, I
immediately had a conversation with
them and provided feedback, both good
and bad, about what I had observed. The
participants then moved on to the second
scenario before completing the post
intervention questionnaire independently.
How did you measure confidence, and
how did you improve it?
Participants completed a questionnaire
before and after the intervention. It
covered 11 aspects of communication
that I thought were integral to how nurses
communicate with patients and other
health professionals. The questionnaire
asks the participant to rate how confident
they are when doing various tasks and is
measured on a Likert scale, from one to 10,
with one being minimally confident and 10
being extremely confident.
Several previous studies have used
communication assessment tools during
their research, but none were able to
be used as an exact replica for my own
study. I took guidance from the format,
wording and aspects of these tools, and
developed my own. Elements included
preparation, greeting, setting the scene,
professionalism, establishing rapport,
maintaining privacy and confidentiality,
active listening, tone and cadence of
speech, use of medical jargon and
terminology, and closure.
At the conclusion of the intervention
(two scenarios and feedback provision)
the participants completed an identical
questionnaire with the aim that there
would be a change (positive or negative) in
their confidence levels.
The integral part of the study was the
intervention – provision of immediate
and personalised feedback following
the first scenario. When providing this
feedback, I endeavoured to address the
elements covered in the questionnaire
and made sure to identify positives and
well as areas of improvement for each
participant.
When discussing aspects they could
work on, I made sure to talk about
strategies they could use to improve their
skills and asked questions about what
(if anything) they had done in the past to
make improvements.
During this time, I also had discussions
with each participant about any previous
experiences that had an impact on their
confidence levels in the hope that talking
about these experiences would help
to identify any further areas they could
improve in.
It was important to provide individualised
feedback specific to behaviours I had
witnessed during their interaction with
the patient in the scenario. It’s not always
possible to provide feedback when
students are on placement in a timely
manner, and having a quick conversation
in the nurse’s station, or worse – at the
patient’s bedside – is hardly ideal or
conducive to positive improvements.
All participants involved in this study
showed a statistically significant
improvement in their perceived self-
confidence after the provision of
immediate, personalised feedback about
their communication skills. How could
we put this work into a medical setting?
The main thing I hoped to achieve
during this research was identifying if an
individualised and personalised approach
to feedback makes a difference.
In the case of the seven participants in
this study, it did. I think we can bring this
into the healthcare setting by identifying
these nurses (as undergraduates and
postgraduates) that are from CALD
backgrounds who may need extra
support as they learn the ways of the
Australian language, our behaviours and
cultural norms.
These nurses can then be offered
additional mentorship and one-on-one
support where they can continue to
have the opportunities to receive this
immediate and personalised feedback on
a regular basis.
However, I do think a really important
aspect is the willingness on the part
of the participants. All participants in
our study came forward on their own
terms – they identified themselves as
someone from a CALD background
who wanted the opportunity to improve
their own confidence levels around their
communication skills.
This willingness and receptiveness to
feedback is integral to see improvements.
For this reason, it is important that we do
not look at this as a blanket rule that all
nurses from culturally and linguistically
diverse backgrounds need additional
mentorship, merely that we develop
a program than enables them to have
additional mentorship if they feel it is
something they would benefit from.
What are the future implications for
CALD nurses?
The main implication I see in my daily
practice is that we (as nurses and
healthcare professionals) need to realise
that confidence levels have an impact on
our theoretical knowledge and our ability
to perform.
Self-doubt is likely something we
have all had to deal with at one point in
our career, and for CALD nurses it is no
different. We need to understand that the
language, behaviours and idioms of the
Australian people are different to what
people may have grown up with in their
home countries.
The Australian population, and our
healthcare workforce, is only going to
become more and more multicultural
and diverse.
We need to embrace the differences
we all bring to the community and foster
the newly graduated nurses that come
into our workplace. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 29